-
Recalibrating crowd twins on real corridor data: one parameter fixes the level, not the slope
Fitting one spacing parameter to Jülich's HERMES runs brings two of four crowd twins within 0.5 s. They still under-price an extra walker.
-
What one more walker costs in a corridor, measured on real crowds, and why the crowd twins get it wrong
On Jülich's HERMES corridor runs, 20% fewer walkers saves people 0.3 to 0.8 s per 8 m. Three of four crowd twins mis-price it by 2 to 7x.
-
A corridor robot that holds the crowd's side saves each person 1.8 to 3.6 s over one that doesn't
A registered crowd-simulation test separates a robot's side from its body: holding the crowd's side gives tidier lanes and seconds shorter walks.
-
Corridor robots don't slow people down; extra bodies do
In three crowd simulators, a robot that keeps to the crowd's side costs people less than the person it replaces. The apparent slow-down was the density control.
-
Corridor robots: holding the crowd's side wins in a third crowd model, and a faster robot is not the fix
In ORCA crowds, robots that hold the crowd's side save people 1.1 to 4.1 s per walk over lateral-goal robots. Faster robots don't stop robots slowing people.
-
ORCA crowds keep right too, and the yielding fix still works
A fifth crowd model, ORCA, keeps 88% of walkers on their right where real people kept 54%; a keep-right bias that yields to the exit brings it to 60%.
-
Three crowd simulators agree on which robot passes people too closely, not on what it costs them in time
ORCA, social force and a collision-free speed model rank four robot passing policies identically by close passes, and differently by human delay.
-
A registered rerun: three crowd simulators still rank corridor-robot policies the same by close passes
With fresh seeds and bootstrap intervals, three crowd models rank four robot passing policies identically by close passes (tau 1.00) but disagree on delay.
-
A corridor robot policy learned in one crowd simulator beat every hand-written policy in all three
A five-parameter robot passing policy trained in each of three crowd twins learned to keep the crowd's side near the wall, and it transferred between twins.
-
The robots that seemed to speed up a crowd were mostly just making room
Crowd-side robots appeared to cut walkers' transit by 1.6 s. With a control that keeps the people count but drops the robots, 88% of the cut is density.
-
Which side should a corridor robot keep? Three crowd models agree only on the wrong answer
In three fitted crowd models, a robot that keeps the side opposite people's convention is worst on every measure; the models disagree on which policy is best.
-
A crowd simulator that trusts the keep-right rule too much
Fitted to nine real corridor runs, a JuPedSim social-force twin kept 78% of walkers on their right once each had a side exit. Real people kept 54%.
-
A fourth crowd model, from another code base, keeps right too
Fitted to real corridor runs, the anticipatory power law kept 97% of walkers on their right under assigned exits. People kept 54%. A yielding bias: 70%.
-
A keep-right rule that yields to the exit
Switching the keep-right bias off for walkers whose exit is on their left, with no refit, brought two of three JuPedSim crowd models close to real crowds.
-
Two crowd models keep right after people stop
Under assigned exits, 54% of real walkers kept right. A social-force twin kept 68 to 78% depending on exit position; JuPedSim's anticipation model kept 99.6%.
-
A second crowd keeps right too, and something on a screen brought the convention back
In a second Jülich corridor experiment 92% of walkers kept right unprompted, 69% once given a side exit, and 99.5% when screens showed something.
-
On a real pavement, people keep right two times in three, even where cars drive on the left
Head-on passes on filmed pavements kept right 65% of the time in Zurich and 68% in Nicosia, against 94% in a lab corridor.
-
People keep right in a corridor, until you give them a door
In real Jülich corridor data 94% of uninstructed walkers kept to their right in near-perfect lanes; assigning each a side exit cut that to 53%.