-
How long should a drone's arms be? Longer, until the design stops being valid
Sweeping the arm on 48 fixed quadrotor tunes: gust crashes fall as the arm grows, with no best length, until the design stops being valid.
-
Raising a drone's tilt limit without retuning: cap what the position error may ask for
Drones tuned at a 20° tilt limit crashed at PX4's 45°. Capping the position loop's proportional request removed every crash for 1–2% of cost.
-
Retuning a drone at a 45° tilt limit bought nothing; a wider gain box bought a lighter, fragile one
Retrained at 45° tilt limit, co-designed quadrotors matched their 20° tune. Given a wider gain box, the optimiser built a lighter drone that needs its cap.
-
Asked for robustness, a drone co-design kept the stiff gain and lengthened its arms
Given a wide gain box and an objective covering an uncertain centre of pressure, a co-designed quadrotor kept a high gain and some mass, and grew longer arms.
-
A longer arm was not why our robust drone design was robust
A fixed-arm control run shows a robust quadrotor co-design gets its robustness from mass and gains, not its longer arms, which help a fixed tune only a little.
-
What a drone frame weighs per millimetre of arm, and why it changed our arm-length result
36 listed FPV frames put a longer quadrotor arm at 0.26 g per mm of wheelbase. At that figure, longer arms buy less gust robustness than we reported.
-
A stable drone still tips over when the motors run out
Quadrotors with a stability margin crashed in a doubled gust lever, tipping over with the mixer saturated. More authority fixed it; airmode, retuning did not.
-
Given more thrust, the drone tuner bought efficiency
Bigger motors stopped a quadrotor's gust crashes but doubled hover power. Given thrust-to-weight as a free variable, the tuner spent it on efficiency.
-
The drone crashed at a tilt limit it was never tuned at
Retrained quadrotors crashed with no gust torque at a 45° tilt limit. Every crash came in the first 0.8 s, recovering from the start offset.
-
Our drone simulator's tilt limit was PX4's minimum
20° is PX4's minimum tilt limit; its default is 45°. At 45°, drone tunes on the linear stability edge fail 13 of 384 simulated flights.
-
The robust drones were the heavy ones
Trained across centre-of-pressure offsets, a co-designed quadrotor halved its gust crashes where fragile, by getting heavier, not by buying thrust.
-
A drone's attitude integrator can cancel a canted rotor's side force, but only with a retune
A feed-forward from the attitude integrator cancelled a canted quadrotor's side force without extra crashes on one frame, but only after a retune.
-
A linear stability test caught every divergence in our canted quadrotor simulations, and flagged too many
An 11-state linear model of a canted quadrotor's control loop missed no divergence in 3,456 simulated flights, but flagged 300 flights that held on.
-
Making the optimiser keep a stability margin cost under 1% and removed the hidden divergences
Simulated quadrotors trained under a linear stability margin lose 0.7% in cost and diverge on 0 of 384 flights at a 45° tilt limit, against 13.
-
How much stability margin should a drone tuner keep? 0.8 of the ceiling, and no less
Sweeping the stability margin in simulated quadrotor tuning: 0.9× the gain ceiling still diverges, 0.8× does not, and tighter buys nothing more.
-
Our guess about why an unstable quadrotor loop stayed bounded was wrong: it was the tilt limit
Simulated quadrotors a linear model calls unstable never diverged. Not the integrator clip: the 20° tilt limit held them; at 45°, 83% of flights diverge.
-
A better attitude controller does not replace rotor cant
We co-designed a quadrotor with INDI and geometric SO(3) control in place of PID. Rotor cant still cut attitude error by 4.2 to 4.9° in 10 of 10 seeds.
-
No real drone has the helpful sign: a canted rotor's side force hurts one axis and helps the other
In simulation, a rigid canted-rotor quadrotor holds position 2–3× worse on one axis after a wind step, whichever side its centre of pressure is on.
-
Cancelling a canted drone's side force in software evens the axes, and adds a rare crash
A feed-forward that leans against a canted quadrotor's own side force removed the one-axis penalty, but a fast filter made some flights diverge.
-
Pricing hover power shrinks the drone, not the rotor cant
When roll, pitch and yaw share one thrust budget, rotor cant's edge grows to 6.1°. Pricing power cuts it 5x, but the chosen cant stays near 32°.
-
Rotor cant survives a second simulator; our ranking test did not
We flew 60 co-designed quadrotors in RotorPy with canted rotors. Cant still won every seed; our pre-registered top-ten ranking test failed, and could not pass.
-
Seven drone projects shared a wrong yaw formula. Rotor cant still wins; the motor result does not
A full allocation shows seven canted-rotor studies understated yaw authority 2-2.8x. Rerun, cant keeps its 4.8° edge; the TWR-5 optimum goes.
-
A canted rotor's side force: harmless or a 21% position penalty, depending on one sign
In simulation, rotor cant cuts quadrotor yaw error 4.7° in position hold. Whether its side force costs position depends on the centre of pressure.