-
Anderson's Gödel argument: when properties have complements, the essence step has a different exact condition
Proved in Lean 4: without rigid positivity, the exact frame condition for the essence step in Anderson's Gödel argument when every property has a complement.
-
Anderson's Gödel argument: the essence step's exact frame condition without rigid positivity
Proved in Lean 4: without rigid positivity, the exact frame condition for the essence step in Anderson's Gödel argument, at every size.
-
Anderson's Gödel argument: an exact frame condition for the essence step, at every size
Proved in Lean 4: with rigid positivity, God-likeness is an essence at w in every model iff every world w sees lies on a cycle.
-
Anderson's Gödel argument: the essence step needs cycles, not reflexivity
Proved in Lean 4, checked on 6.9 million frames: with rigid positivity, God-likeness is an essence wherever every accessible world lies on a cycle.
-
Anderson's ontological argument needs symmetry, not S5
Checked against the Isabelle AFP proof: Anderson's Gödel argument holds in every symmetric frame and fails in S4, in 96,036 of 136,466 models.
-
In Anderson's Gödel argument, the frame conditions depend on which properties exist
Proved in Lean 4: with singleton properties, two steps of Anderson's argument hold in every Kripke frame. God necessarily existing still needs symmetry.
-
From a search up to six cells to a theorem for every model
The models of Anderson's ontological axioms with varying domains, once counted by search, are now characterised by a Lean 4 theorem for any algebra.
-
We conjectured one ontological axiom implied another. Eight cells say no
Plain necessary existence does not imply Anderson's necessary existence: an 8-cell countermodel, proved in Lean 4, and an exact census of 8.5 million frames.
-
Checking our Gödel-argument results against the published Isabelle proofs
All 21 claims of the AFP Isabelle formalisation of Fitting's ontological argument reproduce in our finite models; rigid positivity matters only in K.
-
Fitting's repair of Gödel's argument has the same gap as Anderson's
Fitting's variant of Gödel's ontological argument proves necessary existence de dicto in every model, but de re fails when properties lump individuals together.
-
Anderson's ontological argument gives 'necessarily, something God-like exists', not a necessary being
With varying domains, Anderson's axioms put a God-like being at every world, but not always the same one. A two-world countermodel, checked in Lean 4.
-
We said Anderson's repair of Gödel's proof collapses too. It doesn't, and Lean now proves why
With Anderson's own axiom A2, his repair of Gödel's ontological argument does not force modal collapse: proved in Lean 4, checked on 573 algebras.
-
What it takes to get a necessary God-like being out of Anderson's ontological argument
Making 'exists at every world' a positive property closes the de re gap in Anderson's argument, at the price of a stronger premise than his own.
-
Anderson's ontological argument with varying domains: the conclusion follows, and one axiom carries it
With varying domains, every model of Anderson's axioms has a God-like being at every world, but only via the necessary-existence axiom. Proved in Lean 4.
-
Does Anderson's repair of Gödel's ontological argument survive? It depends on which properties exist
Exhaustive finite-model search: Anderson's emendation collapses to one world under full property semantics, but survives in some restricted property algebras.
-
Anderson's ontological argument: a proof of when it has a model
A proof characterises every finite model of Anderson's Gödel argument: the God-like being has no contingent property; no contingent proposition is a property.
-
Anderson's repair of Gödel's ontological argument still collapses in every small model we can search
Exhaustive search of S5 models up to five cells finds no multi-world model of Anderson's emended Gödel axioms, a prediction we made and lost.
-
Does Shermer's 2% for God follow from his own numbers?
Re-running a published Bayesian estimate of God's existence from its stated inputs gives 0.025%, not 2%.
-
Atheism, Orthodoxy or Catholicism: the arguments machine-checked, the evidence as Bayes factors
Eleven arguments decided by a checker: the ontological argument needs system B, its atheist mirror only T. Christianity's case rests on one Bayes factor.