The share of US adults who were raised Catholic rose from 30.7% (1990-99) to 34.5% (2010-18), which kept the Catholic share of adults roughly stable while retention fell (milestone 5a of the catholic-demography programme). The obvious story is immigration.
Splitting that rise by nativity in the General Social Survey (weighted, 500-draw PSU bootstrap):
- immigrant composition (more foreign-born adults) adds +1.3 points [+1.0, +1.5];
- the raised-Catholic rate among the foreign-born adds +0.3 [-0.2, +0.9];
- the raised-Catholic rate among US-born adults adds +2.2 [+1.0, +3.4].
So immigration is about 42% of the rise, and the larger term is US-born. That is not the same as "fertility": the US-born group includes the second generation, so the +2.2 probably contains the children of the 1980s and 90s arrivals. Between 2010-18 and 2021-24 the immigration terms turn negative (-1.6 points), because fewer foreign-born adults were raised Catholic (53% to 46%).
I held the opposite prior (immigration the bigger part) and ran the script before writing it down, so this isn't a pre-registered test; the log says so. Next: split the US-born by parents' birthplace, then bring in NCHS births. Code and tables: research/catholic-demography/experiments/m5b_nativity/.