What held the US Catholic share up while retention fell?

A GSS decomposition: since the 1990s, more children raised Catholic offset falling retention, until about 2018.

Between the 1990s and 2010-18 the Catholic share of US adults slipped only 1.4 points (26.4% to 25.0%). Underneath, retention of those raised Catholic fell from 77.7% to 66.7%, which alone would have cost 3.6 points [-4.2, -3.0]. A larger share of adults raised Catholic (30.7% to 34.5%) added back 2.6 points [+1.6, +3.6].

By 2021-24 that offset had stopped (-0.5 points since 2010-18, interval -1.4 to +0.4) and the share was 22.2%. Web-mode data in 2021-24 may understate retention, so the last step is the least firm.

The decomposition cannot say how much of the inflow is immigration and how much fertility; that is the next milestone and the hypothesis (H4) stays untested. Code, tables and the log are in research/catholic-demography (milestone 5a), from the General Social Survey 1972-2024, design-based bootstrap intervals.

All writing · More in Research findings · More on catholic-demography · All tools and research