Is the fall in Catholic Mass attendance just a web-survey artefact?

The GSS randomised 2022 and 2024 respondents to face-to-face-first or web-first. Catholic weekly attendance differed by 2.2 points [-3, +8].

Weekly Mass attendance among US Catholics in the General Social Survey fell from 24.0% (2010-18) to 17.7% (2022 and 2024). The surveys also moved from face-to-face to mostly web, so how much of that is real?

The 2022 and 2024 GSS randomly assigned sample cases to a face-to-face-first design or a mail-invitation-to-web-first design. That is a proper experiment, and it is in the public file as modesequence.

Result: Catholics in the face-to-face-first arm reported weekly attendance of 19.4%, in the web-first arm 17.1%. The difference, +2.2 points, has a 95% interval of -3.1 to +7.5. We can't see a mode effect, and we can't rule out one of about five points either way. The face-to-face-first arm alone is still 4.6 points below 2010-18 [0.4, 8.9], roughly three quarters of the full fall. Non-Catholics fell about as much, so it is not a Catholic-specific story.

Completed web interviews report much lower attendance (12.8% against 21.9% in person), but people choose their mode, so that gap is who answers by web, not how they answer.

This is milestone 3b of the open programme on Catholic demography: code, tables and log in research/catholic-demography. Next: reproduce published retention tables, then retention models by cohort, ethnicity and immigrant generation.

All writing · More in Research findings · More on catholic-demography · All tools and research