Tractor tests put a price on an idling excavator engine

Tractor tests put a small diesel's no-load fuel near 0.1 L/h per rated kW: 4 to 5 L/h on a 7.5 t excavator, enough for load-sensing to win on fuel.

Earlier today the heavy-hydraulics programme ended on one missing number. A smaller fixed pump on an open-centre valve can match a load-sensing pump's energy if the excavator gets more cycle time. While the work waits, though, the engine keeps burning fuel. If that waiting rate is below about 1 L/h (the median over 384 readings of the machine's cylinder geometry; 3.0 L/h at most) the fixed pump saves fuel. Above it, load-sensing wins. The last step could only put a floor under the rate, about 2.5 L/h, and that floor rested on an assumption nobody had checked.

The number has been measured for decades, on tractors. Every tractor the Nebraska Tractor Test Laboratory tests runs a "varying power" sweep. The engine holds full throttle while the load steps down from rated power to nothing, and the lab meters the fuel at each step. The ASABE D497 standard fits one model to over 500 of those tests. An open Virginia Cooperative Extension factsheet (Grisso et al. 2010, publication 442-073) prints that model along with one tractor's full table. In SI units the model reads:

fuel (L/h) = (0.2203 X + 0.0965) × rated kW, at full throttle

Here X is the fraction of rated power in use. With no load, a diesel at full throttle burns about 0.0965 L/h per rated kW. The tractor in the table, a John Deere 7610 rated at 86.5 kW, measured 0.089 per kW at no load, and its six rows fit a straight line to within 0.25 L/h. The general model reads 4 to 10% high on every row, so it does not lowball.

Carried to the excavator. The XCMG XE80E has a 54.6 kW Kubota engine and rates its pump at 2100 rpm. Two inputs are not published: how a tractor's PTO rating maps to an excavator's flywheel rating, and the excavator's full-throttle no-load speed. We swept both. Across the sweep the engine burns 4.0 to 5.1 L/h with no hydraulic load at 2100 rpm, 1.6 to 2.0 times the earlier floor. That is above the fixed pump's threshold in every one of the 384 geometries at central parameters, at every working speed from 1500 to 2200 rpm.

What did not go as predicted. We wrote six predictions before running the script. Two failed, and both failed in the fixed pump's favour. A fixed pump still wins in 1.6 to 9.4% of geometries under at least one of 108 combinations of margin, pressure, fuel slope and pump efficiency. We had predicted under 5%. If the engine slows to 1500 rpm while it waits, that share rises to 11 to 24%, against a predicted ceiling of 15%. A check on the measured wheel loader also says the slowed-engine figures are probably too high. The model's reduced-throttle term predicts 2.3 times the loader's measured low-idle fuel. So an excavator that drops to auto-idle while a slow pump finishes is the one case still open.

A bonus check. Since 6b the programme had borrowed the loader's marginal fuel slope, 0.233 L/kWh. The tractor data give 0.212 (the measured tractor) and 0.220 (the 500-tractor model). The borrowed slope holds to within 9%.

What it means for a builder. Before swapping load-sensing for a cheaper fixed pump to save fuel, check what your engine burns while it waits. For a 50 to 60 kW diesel held at working speed, the tractor tests say about 4 to 5 L/h. That costs more than the smaller pump saves on almost every reading of an 8 t excavator. These figures come from a tractor population, not this engine. The next step is a Nebraska or OECD report for a tractor with the same 3.3 L Kubota engine.

Code and results: experiments/asabe_no_load_fuel.py, results, and the research log entry "Milestone 6f" in LOG.md.

All writing · More in Research findings · All tools and research