An idle pump is not free: idle hours help the small fixed pump on an excavator

Charging idle hours to both pumps raised the share of excavator geometries where a smaller fixed pump beats load-sensing on fuel from 67% to 74%.

The heavy-hydraulics programme asks whether a small excavator is better off with a load-sensing pump or a cheaper fixed pump feeding an open-centre valve. Every fuel comparison it has run on the excavator so far counted pump energy only while the machine moves. Real machines spend a lot of engine hours doing nothing. Komatsu's telematics of about 75,000 North American machines put idle at 38% of engine hours, as reported in Construction Equipment in 2020. One manufacturer's 36 t excavator was at about 40%. A Volvo CE fleet of about 450 machines was at 28 to 30%.

The textbook view is that idle is where open-centre loses. Its fixed pump keeps pushing full flow through the valve's neutral passage, while a load-sensing pump destrokes to standby. That is true of the stock pump. It turned out not to be true of the pumps that matter.

A piston pump at zero stroke still drags

Two steps back we fitted a loss model to one measured piston pump (Kauranne, Energies 15:4030, 2022, CC BY). About three quarters of its loss at 150 bar does not shrink with stroke. At zero stroke and 20 bar standby, scaled to the XE80E's 219 L/min pump, that is 2.96 kW of drag, spent just to keep the pump spinning.

A fixed pump at idle pays its own drag plus the neutral pressure drop on its flow. On the Danfoss PVG 32 neutral curve it costs 2.00 kW at 60 L/min, 3.70 kW at 100 L/min and 10.5 kW at the stock 219 L/min. Below 83 L/min it idles cheaper than the load-sensing pump. Two Salami valve readings put the crossover at 91 to 93 L/min.

Where the winners sit

Across the 384 cylinder-geometry readings of the excavator, the best smaller fixed pump is a median 75 L/min, below the crossover. So charging idle hours credits the fixed pump in most geometries. At a 38% idle share a smaller fixed pump beats the tractor-standard no-load fuel rate (3.99 L/h) in 74.0% of geometries, up from 66.7% with motion alone. Across 18 settings (three neutral curves, three standby flows, two idle speeds) the share is 71 to 91%.

I had predicted the opposite: that idle would push the share below 50%. That guess came from the central geometry, the one earlier steps kept quoting. Its best pump is 101 L/min, above the crossover, and there idle does cut the threshold, from 5.64 to 5.07 L/h. For the third step in a row, the central case was the exception rather than the rule.

What it does not settle

The fixed pump in this model is the same piston unit locked at full stroke. A gear pump, the cheap choice a builder would actually make, has its own efficiency and its own spin loss, and we have sourced neither. The idle losses come from a fit below the pressures the pump was measured at. The neutral curves belong to other valves. The idle share is manufacturer data reported by trade press, not a study of this machine. So the claim is narrow: charging idle hours does not rescue load-sensing on this excavator. If anything it makes the smaller fixed pump look better, and the open question is still the fixed pump's own numbers.

Script and output: excavator_idle_standby.py, excavator_idle_standby_results.txt. The six predictions were written down before the script ran. They are in the research log, with the outcome.

All writing · More in Research findings · All tools and research