The gear pump takes it back: a real fixed pump flips the excavator pump choice again

Priced from Casappa's gear-pump curves rather than a piston pump, a smaller fixed pump beats load-sensing on excavator fuel in 10% of geometries, not 74%.

The heavy-hydraulics programme asks whether a small excavator does better with a load-sensing piston pump or a cheaper fixed pump feeding an open-centre valve. Over the last three steps the answer drifted toward the fixed pump. Once the piston pump's drag at part stroke and at idle was charged, a smaller fixed pump beat the tractor-standard no-load fuel rate (3.99 L/h) in 74% of 384 cylinder-geometry readings of the excavator.

Each of those steps ended with the same caveat. The fixed pump in the model was the same piston pump, locked at full stroke, at 0.84 overall efficiency. Nobody puts a locked piston pump on a cheap open-centre machine. They fit a gear pump, and we had no gear-pump numbers.

Reading the catalogue's vectors

Casappa publishes its KAPPA gear-pump catalogue as a PDF. Pages 9 to 11 hold performance curves for eight KP 30 sizes, from 27 to 73 cm³/r. For each size there is flow against speed at 20 bar and at the size's maximum pressure, plus absorbed power and torque against speed at four or five pressures, all measured at 50 °C. The curves are vector drawings, not pictures, so the script reads the Bézier paths straight out of the PDF instead of tracing pixels. It found all 16 flow lines, 35 power curves and 35 torque curves. Power and torque × speed are two separate drawings, and they agree to a median 1.005 (0.977 to 1.037).

At the excavator's 2100 r/min and 150 bar, the gear pumps run at 0.71 to 0.80 overall efficiency. The 44 and 52 cm³/r sizes a machine this size would carry are at 0.76 and 0.78. That is 0.05 to 0.08 below the piston pump. Their zero-pressure drag is no smaller either: 6.5 to 10 bar of their own flow, against the piston pump's 7.9.

What that does to the answer

With the gear pump in place for both the moving and the idle hours, at Komatsu's telematics idle share of 38%:

fixed pumpshare of geometries where it beats 3.99 L/hcentral break-even
piston pump at full stroke (last step)74.0%5.07 L/h
Casappa KP 30, catalogue curves9.9%1.88 L/h
KP 30 at the catalogue's nominal 0.8895.6%6.55 L/h

Across 18 idle settings (three neutral-valve curves, three standby flows, two idle speeds) the gear-pump share stays between 9.6% and 20.6%. Five of the six predictions I wrote before reading a single coordinate were refuted. The worst miss was expecting the fixed pump to keep winning in more than half the geometries.

The catalogue disagrees with itself

The catalogue's formula page says KAPPA pumps reach "overall efficiency (≈ 0,88)". Its own curves say 0.71 to 0.82 between 100 and 200 bar. That gap decides everything. Scaling the curves' efficiency up 5% gives a 29% share, 10% gives 55% and 15% gives 95%. The ranking flips at about 1.09 times the curves, which puts a gear pump at roughly the piston pump's 0.84.

So the programme's open question is no longer a vague "the fixed pump's efficiency". It is a number: does a real gear pump of about 50 cm³/r reach 0.84 at 150 bar and working temperature? If it does, a small open-centre excavator can match load-sensing on fuel in most geometries. If it is nearer its catalogue curves, it cannot. The curves may be drawn conservatively, since the catalogue calls them "approximate selection data", and they were taken at 50 °C rather than the piston pump's 60 °C. An independent test report is the next thing to find.

Code, data and output: digitise_casappa_kappa30.py, casappa_kp30_curves.csv, excavator_gear_pump.py, excavator_gear_pump_results.txt. The predictions and their outcomes are in the research log.

All writing · More in Research findings · All tools and research