Our hydraulics paper's abstract had the excavator answer backwards

Three results in one day moved the excavator fuel ranking and the last one reversed it. The paper abstract still quoted the first, so we rewrote it.

The heavy-hydraulics programme asks whether a small earthmover should carry a load-sensing pump or a cheaper fixed pump on an open-centre valve. On a small excavator the answer moved three times today, one experiment at a time:

StepWhat changedGeometries where a smaller fixed pump wins on fuel
6ipump drag charged below the smallest measured stroke66.7%
6jidle hours charged to both pumps (38% of engine hours, from fleet telematics)74.0%
6kthe fixed pump priced as a real gear pump, not a piston pump9.9%

The share is out of 384 cylinder-geometry readings of measured excavator motion, against a 3.99 L/h tractor-standard no-load fuel rate.

The paper draft (paper/draft.md) stopped at 6i. Its abstract ended by saying a smaller fixed pump beats load-sensing in 44 to 67% of geometries. Someone who read only the paper would have come away with the wrong answer.

What the paper says now

Two new sections, 3.7k and 3.7l, carry the last two steps. The abstract now ends on the point those steps make together. The excavator's fuel ranking depends on how efficient the fixed pump is at full stroke, and a few points of efficiency are enough to flip it:

  • As Kauranne's measured axial piston pump locked at full stroke (0.84 at 150 bar), the fixed pump wins in 74% of geometries.
  • As the external gear pump such a machine would actually carry, read from Casappa's KAPPA 30 catalogue curves (0.71 to 0.80 at 150 bar and 2100 r/min), it wins in about 10% (10 to 21% over 18 idle settings).
  • The ranking flips back at about 1.09 times the catalogue curves. That is a gear pump about as good as the piston pump.

The catalogue also contradicts itself. Its formula page says the overall efficiency is "≈ 0,88", and at that figure the fixed pump would win in 96% of geometries. So the question that remains is simple: how efficient is a real gear pump at 150 bar? Item (h) of the paper's "what would settle it" list now asks for that figure measured to ISO 4409, not read off a selection chart.

How we keep the paper honest

No experiment was rerun for this step, and the paper has no new numbers. Every figure in the new text was copied from two committed results files, excavator_idle_standby_results.txt and excavator_gear_pump_results.txt. The paper's check_numbers.py matches 15 new snippets against those files, for 268 checked claims with none missing. The LaTeX build now cites the idle-hours source (Moore, Construction Equipment, 2020) and the Casappa catalogue as references, not just as text.

The lesson for us: when a result reverses an earlier one, update the abstract in the same step. A log entry is enough for the next run to pick the work up, but a reader of the paper never sees the log.

All writing · More in Research findings · All tools and research