A third gear-pump maker tests our excavator fuel threshold

Two makers' curves put the excavator fuel flip at a gear pump of about 0.83 efficiency. A third maker, never used to fit it, crosses at 0.819.

The heavy-hydraulics programme asks whether a small excavator should carry a load-sensing pump or a smaller fixed gear pump on an open-centre valve, judged on fuel. This morning's step (6n) reduced the answer to one number. A smaller fixed pump starts to win once the gear pump reaches about 0.83 overall efficiency at 150 bar and 2100 r/min, at the pump size the optimum picks (about 85 L/min).

That number came from two manufacturers' published curves, Casappa's and Danfoss's. A threshold fitted on two families mostly describes those two families. It means more only if a family it never saw lands where it says.

The test

Marzocchi's ALP catalogue draws eleven ALP3 gear pumps (20 to 87 cm³/r). It gives flow at 25 bar and at each size's maximum pressure, and absorbed power at 25 to 250 bar, all at 50 °C. The charts are vector paths in the PDF, so we read them exactly rather than by eye (digitise_marzocchi_alp3.py). We wrote six predictions into the log before reading any coordinate. Then we reran the same break-even on 384 cylinder-geometry readings of measured excavator motion.

Casappa KAPPA 30Danfoss SNP3Marzocchi ALP3
efficiency at 150 bar, 2100 r/min0.71 to 0.800.75 to 0.860.80 to 0.91
same, at 85 L/min0.7590.8490.898
smaller fixed pump wins on fuel9.9%70.1%99.5%
efficiency where it crosses 50%0.8280.8310.819

The ALP3 sits well above the threshold, and the fixed pump wins in almost every geometry, as the rule says it should. Because it sits so far above, that check is weak on its own. The sharper test is to scale Marzocchi's curves down until the share falls through 50%. That happens at 0.819, within 0.012 of the other two makers.

What it means

  • The threshold holds out of sample. Three makers' curves, with different shapes across sizes and different idle drag, flip within about 0.01 of each other when the efficiency is read at the size the optimum picks. Read at the family median instead, they spread 0.029.
  • "A gear pump" is not one answer. The three catalogues put the same 85 L/min pump at 0.76, 0.85 and 0.90. That spread is about twelve times the spread of the thresholds. Whether a fixed pump beats load-sensing depends on which pump you buy.
  • The catalogues disagree with themselves. Marzocchi's sizing text says to take 0.95 volumetric and 0.85 hydro-mechanical efficiency, about 0.81 overall: under the threshold. Its own curves are above it. Casappa's text says 0.88 while its curves read 0.71 to 0.80. So what decides it is a measured pump on a test bench (ISO 4409), not a fourth catalogue.

Three of the six predictions held. One of the three that held was empty: Marzocchi's torque curves turned out to be its power curves redrawn, so they could not serve as the independent check we had planned. The refuted ones are in the README ("Milestone 6o"). The paper draft gains section 3.7o, and its abstract now ends on the three-maker result.

Reproduce: python3 experiments/excavator_gear_pump_marzocchi.py in research/heavy-hydraulics (12 s; it needs numpy, h5py and the public excavator-motion dataset).

All writing · More in Research findings · All tools and research