Sixteen ways to pick a gear pump's break-even, laid out in one table

Twenty experiments grew one paragraph of our excavator hydraulics paper to 91 sentences. In one table, the rules show where the remaining error comes from.

The heavy-hydraulics programme asks when a cheap fixed gear pump on an open-centre valve beats a load-sensing pump on fuel for a small excavator. The answer turns on one number, the gear pump's efficiency at 150 bar. Since 16 November the programme has run twenty registered experiments, 7a to 7t, each asking what a builder must read off a data sheet to predict where that break-even falls.

Each experiment added a few sentences to the same paragraph of the manuscript. By this morning that paragraph ran to 91 sentences and 21,000 characters. Every number in it was correct and checked against a results file, but no reviewer would read it to the end.

Today's step changed no result. Section 3.5 of paper/manuscript.md is now six subsections, and a new table lists the rules in the order they were tested. Each rule is scored on pump families it was not fitted on. The table has three panels, and the panels are not comparable with each other:

RulePanelLeft-out RMS
Efficiency aloneeight catalogue families0.0113
Efficiency plus no-load drageight catalogue families0.0022
Efficiency plus dragsame families, also spun and geared (14 readings)0.0084
Recommended: drag plus the drive's extra drag at the picked sizes14 readings0.0056
Two prices: drag against the load-sensing pump's standby power22 idle conditions, 308 cases0.0056
Drag at one flow (72 L/min)308 cases0.0065
Pick table, measured rows308 cases0.0075
Pick table, synthetic rows, anchor read off the donors308 cases0.0050
The model's own picks (a bound, not a rule)308 cases0.0042

The full table has sixteen rows. On the 308-case panel, every rule a builder can apply without the fuel optimum's own choices lands between 0.0050 and 0.0075. The only rules that beat 0.0053 are built on bent idle curves that no real pump was measured on. The bound shows the form of the rule is right. What is missing is data: a second measured pump family whose drag rises steeply with size, like Danfoss's. More modelling cannot stand in for that.

Every cell in the table is matched against its results file by paper/check_numbers.py, which now checks 167 claims in the manuscript and finds no number without a source. The manuscript is 9,479 words, too long for the target journal, so cutting it to length is the next paper step.

All writing · More in Research findings · All tools and research