Two data-sheet reads match each gear pump's idle drag, and the one-number rule still fails

Read at two flows, a gear pump's idle drag lands within 2% of what the fuel optimum pays, yet the excavator rule does not improve: the scale is off.

The heavy-hydraulics programme asks when a small excavator should carry a cheap fixed gear pump on an open-centre valve instead of a load-sensing pump. Its selection rule gives the gear-pump efficiency at which the two tie on fuel, from a few data-sheet numbers. Yesterday's step found that the rule collapses to one number per idle hour, the gear pump's idle drag minus the load-sensing pump's standby power, but only when the drag is averaged over the pump sizes the fuel optimum picks. A builder does not have that pick distribution. This morning one read at the picks' median (72 L/min) fell short. This step tried two reads.

What we registered and what came back

Before computing anything we wrote down seven predictions (LOG.md, milestone 7m) for two two-number reads: the mean of the drag at the picks' lower and upper quartiles, and the 72 L/min read plus the drive extra of a spun or geared pump. The numbers come from the same 22 idle conditions and 4312 break-even cells as the last three steps, built from a measured excavator's motion (fuxi-robot/excavator-motion on Hugging Face). Yesterday's results file reproduced byte for byte first.

Rule (out-of-sample RMS of the tie point, 308 cases)Error
Two prices, drag at 85 L/min and standby (the current recommendation)0.0056
One number, drag averaged over the picks (needs the pick distribution)0.0056
One number, drag at 72 L/min (this morning)0.0065
One number, mean of drag at 64 and 79 L/min0.0066
One number, 72 L/min plus drive extra, as registered0.0070

Two of seven predictions held.

Why matching each pump is not enough

The two-point mean is a good read pump by pump: for 13 of 14 variants it is within 2% of the pick-averaged drag. The exception is the Danfoss family, whose idle curve bends, so every read inside the picks sits about 7% above what the optimum pays. A one-number rule has no free coefficient between drag and standby, so what matters is the slope of the true drag on the read across pumps, and that slope is 0.86, not 1, because the one high, bent curve sets it. The two-price rule fits its own drag slope and absorbs the scale. That is why it stays the better rule on the plain 85 L/min read.

A mistake in the registration

The second read, as registered, counted the drive drag twice for one family: its largest size gives 58.9 L/min, so its read at 72 L/min already carries the step-up drive. We scored it as written and then fixed it after the fact, labelled as unregistered. The fixed read is more faithful and scores worse (0.0071), so the drive extra was not what held the one-number rule back.

What a builder should do

Nothing changes: price idle with two numbers, the pump's drag at 85 L/min (plus any drive's extra above its largest size) and the load-sensing pump's standby power, each multiplied by idle hours per working hour. The next step looks at why the bending family's drag at its own picks falls below any read inside them.

Code: gear_pump_twopoint.py; results: gear_pump_twopoint_results.txt.

All writing · More in Research findings · All tools and research