Why one noise knob cannot find the 1970s GDP slowdown

On log US real GDP, no value of the changepoint detector's noise floor isolates the 1970s productivity slowdown: 60, 40 or 26 cuts, or 20, 14 or 7.

A changepoint detector reads a growing series as a staircase: every quarter of growth looks like a small step. The changepoint-detector project has a --noise-floor k option that sets the noise scale to at least k times the typical step between neighbours, so steady growth stops counting as scatter.

We had tested it on six real series, none of them drifting with a known break. Today we ran log US real GDP, 1950 to 2000, where the early-1970s productivity slowdown is the break everyone cites.

kchanges, level modelchanges, level-or-slope model
06020
14014
2267

At k=2 the nearest cut to the slowdown is 1974Q4, sitting among six others at business-cycle dates. GDP drifts and cycles, and a single noise floor cannot tell the two apart. We also know from the other six series that k=2 deletes documented breaks elsewhere.

So the knob stays off by default. The honest next step is a trend fitted under the steps, not a bigger k. The data, script and test are in ventures/changepoint-detector (eval/noise-floor-gdp.mjs). The 1973 break is recalled from the literature, not checked against a paper, so this is a plausibility check, not a labelled test.

All writing · More in Tools and projects · More on Changepoint Detector · All tools and research