Who goes to Newman Guide colleges? Federal enrolment data, charted

The 14 Newman Guide US colleges with federal data enrol 21,077 undergraduates: whiter, more male and less often on Pell grants than other colleges.

The Cardinal Newman Society's Newman Guide recommends colleges for a strong Catholic identity. The 2026-27 edition lists 24 colleges: 14 US residential colleges, 2 online or non-residential ones, 5 international ones and 3 with provisional recognition. Who actually enrols at them? The federal college database, IPEDS, answers that for 14 of the US schools. Every number below comes from those federal files (fall 2023 enrolment, 2022-23 Pell grants, fall 2023 admissions). The comparison groups are the 199 four-year colleges that IPEDS tags as Roman Catholic and all 2,485 active, degree-granting four-year colleges.

Four US schools on the list have no IPEDS record: Christendom College and Wyoming Catholic College, plus the two new provisional colleges, St. Joseph the Worker and Rosary College. The first two are known for refusing federal student aid, which is probably why, though I have not confirmed it. So the charts cover 12 residential colleges plus Catholic International University and Holy Apostles.

Small schools, 21,077 undergraduates in all

Bar chart of undergraduate enrolment at each Newman Guide college with federal data, from Catholic University of America at 3,139 down to Thomas More College at 95

Taken together, the 14 schools enrol 21,077 undergraduates. That is about 4.5% of the 470,992 undergraduates at Catholic four-year colleges, and fewer than at many single state universities. None has more than 3,200 undergraduates. The median Newman school has 1,427, against 1,648 for Catholic colleges and 1,622 for four-year colleges overall.

How they compare

Grouped bar chart comparing Newman Guide colleges, Catholic four-year colleges and all four-year colleges on sex, race, age, Pell grants and admit rate

Share of undergraduatesNewman Guide (14)Catholic 4-year (199)All 4-year (2,485)
Women54.5%59.4%56.8%
White59.6%53.5%46.9%
Hispanic19.6%18.4%21.0%
Black5.2%8.8%11.5%
Asian3.8%6.4%7.3%
International3.0%4.0%3.5%
Under age 2590.8%90.6%78.2%
Pell grant recipients23.0%25.9%31.4%
Admit rate (of applicants)74.2%66.5%58.3%

Shares are pooled: each group's students are added up first, so a big school counts for more than a small one. What stands out:

  • More men. Women are 54.5% of Newman undergraduates, five points below other Catholic colleges. Belmont Abbey (46.9%) and John Paul the Great (47.3%) enrol more men than women.
  • Whiter, but with one big exception. Six in ten Newman undergraduates are white, against fewer than half nationally. Black and Asian students are underrepresented by roughly half.
  • Traditional age. 91% are under 25, the same as at Catholic colleges and well above the 78% national figure.
  • Somewhat better off. 23% receive a Pell grant, the federal grant for low-income students, against 31% nationally.
  • Not selective as a group. Newman colleges admit three applicants in four, which is more than average. Ave Maria (45%) and the University of Dallas (54%) are the exceptions.

One Houston university carries the Hispanic share

Paired bars of white and Hispanic undergraduate shares at each Newman Guide college with 250 or more undergraduates, led by University of St Thomas Houston at 52% Hispanic

The group's Hispanic share, 19.6%, looks close to the national figure. That is mostly the University of St. Thomas in Houston, which is 52% Hispanic and has nearly 3,000 undergraduates. Without it, the other 13 schools are 14.2% Hispanic and 66.4% white. John Paul the Great (33%) and the University of Dallas (28%) are the only others above a quarter. The Catholic Church in the United States is increasingly Hispanic, but most Newman colleges do not yet reflect that.

What this can't tell you

IPEDS counts race, sex, age and aid. It says nothing about religion, so this data cannot tell you how many students are practising Catholics. That figure would come from the colleges' own surveys, which are not federal data. Some details need care:

  • The University of Mary reports zero Hispanic undergraduates and 280 of unknown race, so its Hispanic share is probably understated.
  • Thomas Aquinas College has two campuses, and I found only one IPEDS ID. Whether that record includes the Massachusetts campus is unconfirmed.
  • At the two smallest schools (fewer than 100 undergraduates), a handful of students moves a percentage by several points.

Reproduce it

The list with its IPEDS IDs is in newman_colleges.csv. newman_ipeds.py rebuilds the per-college and group tables from the free NCES IPEDS data files (HD2024, IC2024, EF2023A, EF2023B, SFA2223, ADM2023), and newman_charts.py redraws the charts. Companion posts look at Latin Mass attendees and FOCUS and other Catholic missionaries.

All writing · More in Tools and projects · All tools and research