-
A slope runs straight, a compounding gap bends: telling them apart in a synthetic control
On GDP-like panels a donor's own slope hides among gaps that all grow. Reading each gap's curvature finds it more sharply. Pre-registered, 32,000 panels.
-
Scored where it switches on, the panel shape word hides a donor's own slope
A pre-registered re-test on 32,000 simulated panels: read against a compounding panel, a donor's own big slope is called 'held' 90% of the time.
-
When every gap grows: reading a synthetic control's placebos against the panel's own trend
A panel-relative shape word cut wrongly named units on compounding panels from 80% to 22%, but missed one pre-registered bar by 0.4 points, so it does not ship.
-
When every country's gap grew: a panel-relative word, offered but not the default
On West Germany 1990 the plain word called 12 of 16 placebo gaps 'grew'. Read against the panel it names 2. Why it is an opt-in, with the numbers.
-
When people see the change coming: backdating a synthetic control, tested
An effect that starts 2-4 points early loses up to three fifths of a synthetic control's power. Backdating wins it back; the placebo warning half-holds.
-
Comparing a handful of stores? One store with its own bad month can hide a real effect
With 11 to 21 units, a real effect reaches rank 1 in about 57% of simulated panels. One donor with its own shock cuts that to 38%, or 9%. Leave it out first.
-
Not sure when people started reacting? Test every lead at once without fooling yourself
Running a synthetic control at five backdates and keeping the best p doubles false alarms. A range test finds nearly as much with none of that cost.
-
A promotion that wore off beats a lasting change: donor events that are not steps, in a synthetic control
With 11 to 16 units, one donor's short burst leaves a real effect at rank 1 only 12-14% of the time, against 37-40% for a step of the same average size.
-
Sixteen donors can't give you p 0.05: a synthetic control on West Germany and the Basque Country
Two classic 17-unit panels through the shipped synthetic control: both published gaps come back, neither ranks first, and p 0.05 was never reachable.
-
When a covariate's shock is a slope or a fading pulse, does the synthetic control's warning still hold?
Pre-registered, 2,000 panels: the placebo warning held 42 of 43 false findings under slope and pulse covariate shocks. A pulse fools the test, then fades.
-
Two stores with their own bad months, and the one you leave out: a synthetic control simulation
With 11 to 16 units, two donors with their own shocks halve a real effect's rank-1 rate. Leaving out one is not enough; a shocked best match moves the gap.
-
Flooring one denominator puts California first again on Proposition 99
Flooring the before-gap at the median puts California 1st of 39 on Proposition 99, as published, and lifts simulated power from 34% to 57%.
-
A synthetic control from the command line, and a warning that doesn't always name the culprit
The changepoint detector's CLI now runs a synthetic control with a balance table. A pre-registered two-covariate test shows the warning's limits.
-
Adding covariates to the Proposition 99 synthetic control made the test worse
Matching on income, price and three lags helped Massachusetts and Arizona, but dropped California to 2nd of 39 and broke Oregon's fit.
-
A synthetic control in the browser: paste a wide CSV, name the date, read the balance table
The changepoint detector's page now runs a synthetic control with placebo test and covariate balance warnings, all in the tab. No install, no upload.
-
A synthetic control for Proposition 99: the right gap, the wrong rank
An outcome-only synthetic control recovers California's 26-pack Proposition 99 gap, but two near-perfect donor fits push its placebo rank to 3rd of 39.
-
Six starts for the synthetic control's V search, and why Oregon still can't be matched
A multi-start search for V tightened the Proposition 99 fits but moved no state into significance. No V on these predictors fits Oregon.
-
Proposition 99's synthetic California is matched on sales, not on income
Covariate balance of the outcome-only synthetic control: California's synthetic twin is 1.66 sd poorer, and Massachusetts is balanced yet still not found.
-
Which covariate imbalance biases a synthetic control? Ask the placebos, not the 0.25 rule
A pre-registered simulation: the 0.25 sd balance flag fires on 84% of fits regardless; 'placebos matched better' at 80% holds every false finding.
-
Synthetic control in a browser tab, and how the placebo screen changes the p-value
A free synthetic control tool reproduces the West Germany weights. On the same data the placebo p-value runs from 0.059 to 1 on one screening choice.