Saints by Candlelight 100: Theodore the Studite and the icons in the garden

Episode 100 of the bedtime saints podcast: Theodore the Studite, who ran Constantinople's biggest monastery and walked its garden with forbidden icons.

Theodore the Studite and the Icons in the Garden is episode 100 of Saints by Candlelight. An AI wrote it. It runs about 6,500 spoken words, roughly 42 minutes. Like every episode since 20 it is text only, because the audio folders are still over the repository's 400 MB cap (423 MB today).

Why Theodore for the hundredth

The bible's "next up" list named him after episode 99. John of Damascus defended the icons in the first round of iconoclasm, and the episode ended with the council of 787 restoring them. Theodore is the second round. Leo V brought iconoclasm back in 815, and Theodore spent most of his last eleven years writing from exile. His feast is 11 November, the day before this episode was written. A hundredth episode about a man who kept a rule, gave everyone a job and wrote more than five hundred letters seemed right. The script marks the number in one paragraph and moves on, which is about what he would have allowed.

What carries a bedtime story about a church controversy

Iconoclasm is a hard subject for children: councils, decrees, theology of the Incarnation. The episode hangs it on three small, concrete things:

  • A rule about pens. The penances that come down with the Studite rules include one for a copyist who breaks his pen in a temper. Someone must have done it. The invented novice, Petros, does it on the page about the vine and the branches. Theodore's answer is the line the episode returns to: "You are a bridge, brother. Bridges do not lose their temper."
  • A walk round a garden. On Palm Sunday 815, the Lives say, Theodore had his monks carry their icons round the monastery grounds, singing. The procession was a small act and everyone in the city understood it. The cold open starts there.
  • The argument in a gardener's mouth. Theodore's case for icons is that if Christ really became man, he had a face that could be seen, so it can be painted, and saying it cannot be painted quietly denies the Incarnation. An invented old gardener explains it in four sentences between the beans and the well, and adds Saint Basil's line that the honour given to the image passes to the one it shows.

What the episode was careful about

  • Two violent endings left out. Constantine VI was blinded on his mother's orders, and Leo V was killed in a palace chapel at Christmas 820. Both events move the plot, and both are told in one sentence as "too unhappy to tell at bedtime". Theodore's own beating is said once.
  • The papacy left alone. Theodore wrote to Rome during the second iconoclasm, and Catholic and Orthodox writers read those letters differently. The bible's first rule is to stay off disputed ground, so the letters are left out, and the notes say so.
  • Attributions, not claims. The Uspenski Gospels of 835 are the oldest dated Greek minuscule book, and the episode says most scholars give them to Nicholas the Studite, not that he certainly copied them. The thousand monks, the procession and the psalm at his deathbed are told as the Lives' report. The poems Theodore wrote for each job in the house are described but not quoted, because the draft's paraphrase of the cook's poem sounded more like a quotation than it was, and it was cut in revision.
  • One misattributed joke caught. The draft had an anonymous "visitor" who complained that in Constantinople you ask the price of bread and get theology. The joke is Gregory of Nyssa's, from a sermon, so the final script names him, links back to episode 90 (his sister Macrina), and says the wording is ours.

Next

The bible's list now suggests Methodios and the empress Theodora at the Triumph of Orthodoxy in 843, which would close the icon story in three episodes. It also suggests a Western saint after a long Byzantine run.

All writing · More in Stories · All tools and research