If you are self-employed and also have tax withheld somewhere (a part-time job, a spouse's paycheck, a pension), the IRS counts that withholding in one of two ways when it works out the penalty for paying estimated tax late:
- By default, a quarter of the year's withholding counts as paid on each of the four estimated-tax dates, whenever it was really taken out. The Form 2210 instructions ("Line 11") say you are "considered to have paid one-fourth of these amounts on each payment due date unless you can show otherwise."
- With box D checked on Form 2210, each withholding counts on the date it was actually withheld. You then have to file the form and be able to show the dates.
Neither one is always better. It depends on when the tax came out.
One set of books, three penalties
Made-up books for 2025: a single filer earns $80,000 in January and nothing after, sends no estimates, and has $12,000 withheld in one lump. The AI Bookkeeper annualized worksheet gives:
| When the $12,000 was withheld | Default (a quarter a date) | Box D (actual date) |
|---|---|---|
| February 15, 2025 | $285.25 | $52.15 |
| December 15, 2025 | $285.25 | $686.65 |
The default doesn't care about the date, so it gives $285.25 both times. Withholding in February covers the April installment and the ones after it, so box D drops the penalty to $52.15. Withholding in December covers nothing until January, so box D would push the penalty up to $686.65, and the right move is to leave it unchecked.
The December case is the well-known tip: if you are behind on estimates, raising withholding late in the year can fix it, because the default spreads it back over the whole year. The February case is the reverse, and people miss it: with tax withheld early in the year, a penalty can fall by about 80% if you check one box.
The tool now takes dated withholding (--withheld 2025-02-15:12000 on the command line, or "Tax withheld, with dates" on the page), works out both methods with and without box C (the annualized income method), and says which boxes lower the penalty. Withholding still never goes on line 1b of the penalty worksheet, which the instructions say only payments can reach.
The 2026 form is already posted
The IRS has an early-release draft of the 2026 Form 2210 on irs.gov (irs-dft/f2210--dft.pdf, "Created 4/16/26"). We read it with pdftotext and compared it line by line against the 2025 form. Apart from the years, three things changed:
- Schedule AI line 29, the prorated social security limit, now prints $46,125, $76,875, $123,000 and $184,500. That is the 2026 wage base of $184,500 prorated over 3, 5, 8 and 12 months. The tool already used that figure, but its only source so far was search excerpts of SSA pages, which we can't fetch from here. Now an IRS form prints it, and a test pins it.
- A new line 9b, "Additional deductions", sits beside the qualified business income deduction. The draft instructions posted next to it are still the 2025 text, so what goes on 9b is not printed yet. The 2025 instructions put the new Schedule 1-A deductions (tips, overtime, car-loan interest, the senior deduction) into a line 14 adjustment, and 9b looks like their new home. The worksheet takes the senior deduction. It does not take tips, overtime or car-loan interest, and it says so in every result.
- Part I line 3 is renamed "Refundable credits and other adjustments."
Each result now says which form it follows: the final 2025 form, the 2026 draft, or, for later years, a form nobody has read yet.
Limits
This is a worksheet, not tax advice. It assumes the payments you list are all you made. It doesn't model the January 31 file-and-pay rule or waivers. The 2026 figures come from a draft the IRS may still change. Form 2210 and its instructions decide.