The cell-fidelity programme forecasts how much lithium a battery electrode design loses to plating over 100 cycles from a short run of the full DFN model. The forecast is a kinetic law with one exponent. The physical value, αF/RT = 25.3 per volt, is too shallow on the LG M50 cell, and the previous milestone series ended with a mechanism: the exponent the forecast needs is 25.3 times the ratio of the open-circuit potential rise where the plating happens to the law's own potential lever. Read over 100 cycles, that ratio lands within 3 to 12% of the needed exponent on three of four PyBaMM cell models.
That was a diagnosis, because it reads cycle 99. Milestone 5zm asked the question a design search cares about: how many cycles does the ratio need before it can be trusted?
How it was tested
No new simulation. The same 40 DFN designs (PyBaMM 26.10.1.1, four parameter sets, SEI and plating, 100 cycles each), whose per-node potentials and plating currents were already committed. For a budget of k cycles (10, 20, 30, 50), the ratio was fitted over cycles 3 to k only, and two forecasts of the cycle-99 loss were given the same k cycles: the law at the early exponent, and the law at the physical 25.3. Four hypotheses and their thresholds were committed before any early-window number was computed.
What it found
| set | needed exponent | read at 10 cycles | at 30 | at 99 |
|---|---|---|---|---|
Chen2020 (LG M50) | 36.6 | 100 (clamp) | 98.2 | 37.7 |
OKane2022 (LG M50) | 32.3 | 48.7 | 75.0 | 34.2 |
Ai2020 | 18.8 | 43.1 | 24.0 | 25.2 |
NCA_Kim2011 | 23.6 | 29.4 | 27.4 | 26.4 |
(Set medians, 8 to 12 designs each.) On LG M50 the early reading is two to three times too high, and a forecast built on it loses to plain physics. Over all four sets the early exponent lost on 4 of 4 at ten cycles and on 3 of 4 at thirty. Two hypotheses were refuted and two came out inconclusive.
The reason is in the shape, not the noise. While the LG M50 graphite sits on its voltage plateau at top of charge, the law's lever barely moves (0.4 mV by cycle 10 on Chen2020). Inside the electrode, where most of the plating is, the potential has already risen 2.9 mV. The ratio starts near 6 and falls toward 1.2 as lost lithium pushes the law's window off the plateau. So the 100-cycle ratio is an average over a changing path, dominated by late cycles, not a constant of the design that early cycles reveal. On NCA_Kim2011, with no plateau at top of charge, the ratio is flat from cycle 10.
The practical answer
The comparison held one plain result that nobody had hypothesised: give the law at the physical exponent more cycles to fit its line, and it gets better on every set. The cycle-99 lithium-loss error goes from 8.2% at ten cycles to 4.6% at thirty and 2.0% at fifty on Chen2020, and from 5.9% to 1.7% on OKane2022. A search that can afford 30 to 50 DFN cycles per finalist does better that way than with any early exponent tested here.
The next mechanism step is a lever that knows about the plateau: read the potential at the plating-weighted stoichiometry on the open-circuit curve, and check it against the falling ratio measured here.
Limits: 40 designs already seen by earlier milestones, one PyBaMM version, node potentials that are a model internal rather than a cell measurement, and modelled fade only. Code, data and the log are in the project directory; this step's output is experiments/horizon10/.