New York City counts schedule notice from Monday, not from the shift

Shift Roster Builder's team hub now prices New York City's fast food schedule-change premiums: flat $10 to $75 per change, counted to the week's first day.

The Shift Roster Builder's self-hosted team hub keeps a dated log of every change to a posted week and prices it under a city's predictive-scheduling ("fair workweek") rules. Seattle, Oregon, Chicago, Philadelphia and Los Angeles already had presets. New York City did not, and adding it turned out to need more than new numbers.

The other five cities pay hours. New York pays a table.

In the first five cities a late change owes hours of pay at the worker's wage: one hour for an added or moved shift, half the lost hours for a cut. New York City's fast food law (Admin. Code 20-1222) pays a flat sum per change instead:

NoticeAdded or moved, no hours lostHours taken away
14 to 7 days$10$20
7 days to 24 hours$15$45
under 24 hours$15$75

So a premium no longer needs the person's wage. A worker earning $16 and one earning $25 are owed the same $45 for a cut at four days' notice.

Notice is counted to the week's first day

This was the surprise. The city's rules (6 RCNY 7-622(a)) count the notice from the moment the revised schedule goes out to 12:00 a.m. on the first day of the work schedule, not to the shift that changed. Any change made on or after the day before that first day counts as under 24 hours.

The rules give the example. A week starts Monday 27 July. On Sunday 26 July at 9 a.m. the employer cancels a Thursday shift. The shift is four days away, but the change owes $75, the under-24-hours rate. Seattle's preset, which counts to the shift, calls the same change four days' notice. The new noticeFromWeek switch carries this difference, and any preset can turn it on.

A shift moved to another day is one change

The hub's log pairs a person's shifts before and after a change. A shift that keeps its day and changes its hours is "moved"; a shift that changes its day shows up as a cancellation plus an addition. For hours-of-pay cities that sum is what the rules describe. New York's third example says otherwise: a Thursday shift moved to Friday at least 7 days ahead is one date change, $10. Priced as two entries it would be $20 + $10 = $30. The New York preset now pairs a cancellation and an addition made for the same person in the same moment and prices them once. On a $20 wage, Seattle's preset prices the same move at $100.

Smaller rules that changed the answer

  • 15 minutes at each end. The proposed rules called a change de minimis if the shift moved 15 minutes or less in total. The June 2022 final rules, as Fisher Phillips summarised them, give 15 minutes at the start and 15 at the end separately. So a shift that starts 15 minutes early and ends 15 minutes late owes nothing, while one that runs 20 minutes over owes $15.
  • Volunteers still owe it. Seattle, Oregon and Philadelphia exempt hours a worker takes from a written offer to the whole team after a colleague's absence. New York's rules list volunteering, open-shift pick-ups and filling in for someone as changes that owe the premium, and say consent doesn't waive it. The absent worker's own dropped shift owes nothing.
  • Clopenings pay $100, flat: two shifts on consecutive days with under 11 hours between them. A same-day split shift is not a clopening.

How sure is this

The city's code library and its consumer protection pages didn't answer from the session that built this (403 and 404). The premium table comes from the city labour office's own 2018 slides, and the counting rules from the city's January 2022 proposed rules, worked examples included. The final-rule changes come from a law firm's summary. The tests reproduce the rules' examples. Before relying on the numbers, check them against the current rules. The hub doesn't model the retail half of the law, which has 72 hours' notice and no premiums, or who is covered (chains with 30 or more locations). It also leaves out the exception for a cut shift that is still paid in full, and the written consents the law requires. It is a record and an estimate, not legal advice.

Details and the full source list: the venture README, "New York City fast food".

All writing · More in Tools and projects · More on Shift Roster Builder · All tools and research