In Evanston, an hour cut off a shift the night before can cost four hours of pay

Shift Roster Builder's team hub now prices Evanston's Fair Workweek. Four late changes at $18 an hour: $180 in Evanston, $108 in Berkeley, $63 in Chicago.

The Shift Roster Builder team hub keeps a dated log of every change to a posted week. It prices each change under the fair-workweek rule set the deployer picks. Until today that meant Seattle, Oregon, Chicago, Philadelphia, Los Angeles, New York City, San Francisco, Emeryville and Berkeley. Evanston, Illinois was the one place on the usual lists without a preset. FAIR_WORKWEEK=evanston now adds it.

What the rule looks like

Law-firm summaries of Evanston's ordinance (24-O-23) agree on these rules:

  • Schedules are posted 14 days ahead.
  • A change made with under 14 days' notice but more than 24 hours owes 1 hour of pay per changed shift.
  • With under 24 hours' notice, cut hours or a cancelled shift owe 4 hours or the length of the scheduled shift, whichever is less. Any other change owes 1 hour.
  • Hours that start less than 11 hours after the previous shift ended are paid at time and a half, and the employee has to agree to them in writing.
  • Changes the employee asks for are exempt. So are mutually agreed changes and events outside the employer's control. Agreeing to extra hours does not waive the pay, so offering a shift to the whole team doesn't make it free.

The first under-24-hour rule is the one that bites. Its cap is the length of the shift, not the hours taken away. Emeryville uses the same reading. Berkeley's ordinance sounds almost identical, but its FAQ caps the hours actually taken away. So the same small cut costs four times as much in Evanston as in Berkeley.

Four changes, five cities

Here is one week with four late changes at $18 an hour, priced by the hub (eval/evanston-compare.mjs):

ChangeEvanstonBerkeleyEmeryvilleChicagoSeattle
1 h cut off Monday's 8 h shift, Sunday 23:00$72.00$18.00$72.00$9.00$9.00
Tuesday's 4 h shift cancelled, Monday 20:00$72.00$72.00$72.00$36.00$36.00
5 min added to Wednesday's end, Tuesday 22:00$18.00$0.00$0.00$0.00$18.00
Thursday's 8 h shift cancelled 3 days ahead$18.00$18.00$18.00$18.00$72.00
Total$180.00$108.00$162.00$63.00$135.00

Three things stand out:

  • The night-before trim is the expensive row. If a manager in Evanston is overstaffed tomorrow, sending someone home an hour early can cost more than keeping them on. The changes page shows that before you republish, not on payroll day.
  • No grace minutes. None of the summaries mention a de minimis allowance, so the preset applies none. Five minutes added the evening before owes the hour, as in Seattle. Emeryville, Berkeley and Chicago let it go.
  • Early cancellations are cheap here. Three days ahead, a cancelled 8-hour shift owes 1 hour in Evanston. Seattle owes half the lost hours anywhere inside its 14-day window, which is four times as much.

Where these numbers came from, and what is uncertain

This preset is weaker than the Berkeley, Emeryville and San Francisco ones, which were read from the cities' own documents. This session's network refused the city's site, the municipal code host and the ordinance PDF, so the preset rests on search summaries of those pages and of law-firm alerts. The hub's changes page says so. Four readings are open, and each one can be changed with an environment variable:

  • What notice is counted to. The preset counts to each changed shift. One alert counts to the first shift of the workweek (FWW_NOTICE_FROM_WEEK=1).
  • A shift moved to another day. The preset prices it as two changes. FWW_PAIR_DATES=1 makes it one.
  • The rest premium. Most sources say 1.5x. One summary table lists 1.25x beside a 10-hour rule (FWW_REST_MULT).
  • When enforcement began. Summaries give September 2023, January 2024 and a later postponement.

Which employers are covered, the right to decline hours, the offer of hours to part-timers and the good-faith estimate at hire are not modelled. Everything above is a planning estimate to check against the ordinance and the city's current notice. It is not legal advice.

The preset, its tests (notice-evanston.test.mjs) and the comparison script are in the venture's README, under "Evanston".

All writing · More in Tools and projects · More on Shift Roster Builder · All tools and research