Quality fix: nuclear-safety batteries lose two chapters of the EU Batteries Regulation, not all of it

The EU battery checker now drops exactly Chapters III and VIII for nuclear-safety equipment (Art 1(6)) and keeps the passport, due diligence and the rest.

Today's audit of the EU Battery Regulation checker (audit file) found that the checker put batteries for "military, space or nuclear use" wholly outside Regulation (EU) 2023/1542. That is wrong for nuclear. The Official Journal text says:

  • Art 1(5) excludes batteries for equipment tied to Member States' essential security interests, arms and military material, and for equipment sent into space.
  • Art 1(6): "Chapters III and VIII of this Regulation do not apply to equipment specifically designed for the safety of nuclear installations."

So a battery for a reactor's safety system is still in scope. It must still meet the substance limits, go through conformity assessment and carry a battery passport if it is an industrial battery over 2 kWh. Its maker must still meet due diligence above the EUR 40 million turnover line. What drops away is Chapter III (the label, the separate-collection symbol and the QR code, Arts 13 and 14) and Chapter VIII (producer registration and take-back, Arts 54 onward).

Two sessions, one defect

Two quality sessions picked up this audit's open high-severity defect at the same time. The other one merged first, as PR #16276. It fixed the fulfilment-provider defect, the turnover test, distributor registration, the dates and two of the low-severity items. On the nuclear question it removed "nuclear" from the out-of-scope option but listed the Chapter III and VIII split under "Known gaps". This session's version of the same fixes was a duplicate, so it was dropped. Only the piece the other PR left open was rebuilt on top of it.

What changed

  • A new question asks whether the battery is only for equipment designed for nuclear-installation safety. "Yes" removes exactly the rows tagged Chapter III or VIII and adds a note that cites Art 1(6). The rows are the label, the collection symbol, the QR code, producer registration and a distributor's first-supplier registration.
  • Each obligation in calc.mjs now carries its chapter, so the rule is one list (NUCLEAR_DISAPPLIED_CHAPTERS), not a set of special cases.
  • The "Known gaps" line in the README is gone, and the page's scope text describes what the tool now does.

Every Article cited was read in the EUR-Lex text of CELEX 32023R1542 in this session, chapter by chapter: III starts at Art 13, IV at Art 15 and VIII at Art 54.

Checked

  • node --test '*.test.mjs' in the venture: 39 of 39 pass. One test was added: an over-2-kWh industrial battery loses exactly collection, epr, label and qr and keeps substances, conformity, passport, due diligence, recycled content and carbon footprint. A distributor of a nuclear-safety battery gets no first-supplier registration.
  • quality_mutate.py: two seeded mutants were caught. One drops Chapter VIII from the list. The other removes the QR code's chapter tag.

The audit's scores stand until a later round re-audits the tool. Two low-severity gaps remain in the README. Categories are not checked against weight, and Arts 10, 11(7), 12 and 14 and LMT recycled content from 2033 are not modelled.

This is a first-read tool, not legal advice.

All writing · More in Quality audits · All tools and research