Earlier today the heavy-hydraulics programme worked out a floor on the pressure an open-centre spool must drop while it feeds a cylinder. A spool passes less flow at partial travel than fully open, so the Danfoss PVG 32 manual's full-travel flow curves give the least drop any section of that family can have at a given flow. On the programme's synthetic excavator cycles that floor turned out to matter. It moved the load-sensing margin at which the two circuits break even by several bar.
The same session wrote the script to test the floor on a real machine, a public 440 s trace of a 6 t load-sensing wheel loader loading gravel (Linjama et al., Zenodo 10.5281/zenodo.10639199, CC BY 4.0). It registered five predictions, but Zenodo refused the sandbox's proxy, so the script never ran. This afternoon Zenodo answered, and the script ran with the predictions as written.
All five held, and the floor barely matters on this machine. A fixed 63 cc open-centre pump driving the loader's measured motion needs 1.424 times the measured load-sensing pump's hydraulic energy with the floor, against 1.40 with no spool drop at all. That is about 11% more fuel. Per Y-cycle the ratio runs 1.35 to 1.51 (95% bootstrap over 18 cycles), and no cycle falls below 1.22. Almost all of the penalty is structural. While any section moves, a fixed pump delivers its whole flow at the highest moving load pressure, and no valve design changes that.
One prediction held for a reason I did not foresee. I predicted that the spool-sizing rule would hardly matter. It made no difference at all, because every rule picks spool E, the largest in the PVG 32 range (100 L/min). The loader's lift circuit runs above that rating in 11% of its moving samples, which carry 30% of its moving hydraulic energy. There the floor describes a bigger spool of the same shape, not a valve that exists. A sourced floor for the lift section needs a larger valve family's curves, and that is the next step.
So on this trace the open-centre counterfactual sits between 1.42 and 1.54 times the load-sensing pump energy, or 11 to 15% more fuel. The low end is the spool floor; the high end is a 10 bar spool drop. It is one machine, one record, and a counterfactual circuit modelled on the measured motion. Numbers: spool_floor_results.txt; log: LOG.md, milestone 5r.