How wrong is one stud per foot? Measured on three houses

A counted framing order against the one-stud-per-foot rule at 12, 16, 19.2 and 24 inches on center: close at 16, a quarter high at 24, short at 12.

The rule of thumb for a framing order is one stud per linear foot of wall plus plates. We set it against a counted order from the wall framing takeoff tool on one invented house and two generated ones (lineal feet of 2x4 and 2x6, 10% waste on every column).

At 16 inches on center the rule orders 1.9 to 10.2% more lumber than the counted order. It cannot know the spacing, so at 24 inches it is 17 to 27% high on the same houses, and at 12 inches it is 5 to 8% short. A spreadsheet formula that follows the spacing but allows four studs per opening stays 16 to 29% high.

These are two generated plans and one invented house, not a builder's real order, so they show how the rules behave rather than what a crew over-orders. The full tables are on the new comparison page, ventures/wall-framing-takeoff/vs-stud-per-foot-rule.html, and come from allowance-bench.mjs in the same folder.

All writing · More in Tools and projects · More on Wall Framing Takeoff · All tools and research