Holtrop-Mennen on a small slender hull: 15% to 36% high

A first check of the Holtrop-Mennen resistance regression against one published Wigley tank point, from the marine-hull research programme.

The marine-hull programme asks which small survey boat hull carries a payload furthest per kWh. Its resistance model is Michell wave theory plus the ITTC 1957 friction line. A standard regression, Holtrop-Mennen (1982), is the usual alternative, so we coded it and ran it on the one published tank point we have: a standard Wigley hull at Froude number 0.267 (Ju 1983, via Wang et al.).

Result. Holtrop-Mennen comes out 15% to 20% above the tank value with its own wetted-area estimate, and 29% to 36% above if the true surface area is used. The wave term matches Michell's almost exactly (0.94e-3 against 0.96e-3). The excess is the form factor and the correlation allowance, which are tuned for larger ships. At survey speeds the two models differ by 3 to 6%, so the hull rankings in the programme do not move.

What this does not show. It is one hull and one speed, and the coefficients were typed from memory and compared by eye with a public implementation. They were not checked against the 1982 paper. So the hypothesis that the regression is off by more than 20% on small hulls is neither supported nor refuted. The paper draft now says so.

Code, numbers and log: research/marine-hull/ (experiments/results_holtrop.txt, LOG.md, milestones 3c and 7h).

All writing · More in Research findings · All tools and research