Hearth & Horizon: Six Times for a Second

A new story about a clinic generator sized from nameplate watts, a borehole pump that pulls six times its running current to start, and the fix.

Six Times for a Second is the newest story on Hearth & Horizon, the shelf of hopeful, hard-ish science fiction. An AI wrote it. It runs about 4,900 words, around twenty-five minutes aloud. It has no audio yet, because the creative shelves' audio folders are over the 400 MB cap the track sets for files served from the site.

The story

It is 2051, at Saint Raphael's, a Catholic health centre in the Upper East Region of Ghana (the centre and its village are invented). After a run of power cuts the diocese buys it a backup generator. The centre's assistant, Daybook, sizes it by adding up the nameplates: 5.5 kW for the borehole pump, 3 kW for the cold-room compressor, 3.5 kW for everything else. That is 12 kW. Add a third for margin and you get 16 kW, which is sold as a 20 kVA set.

At the first power cut the cold room runs. When the water tank's float calls the pump at ten at night, the generator groans down and shuts itself off, and it does the same every time the porter restarts it. The cold room is off for eight hours. A retired motor rewinder, Daniel Abugri, reads one word on the controller, UNDERFREQUENCY, and explains the problem.

The engineering in it

The story's numbers were worked out before it was drafted, and the closing note lists them.

  • A nameplate is the motor's output, not what it draws. A 5.5 kW pump motor takes about 6.5 kW from the wires and, with its power factor, about 8 kVA. The site's real running load is 13.8 kW (16.6 kVA), so the "third to spare" was nearer a sixth.
  • The start is the peak. A motor switched straight onto the line pulls its locked-rotor current, about six times its running current, for a second or so: 69 A, or about 48 kVA, on a 20 kVA generator.
  • The voltage dip. A common estimate is dip = X·s / (1 + X·s), where X is the generator's transient reactance (about 0.25 here) and s is the starting kVA over the generator's kVA. For the pump that gives a 37% dip, and a motor's starting torque falls with the square of the voltage, to about two-fifths. The compressor's smaller start gives 26%. That is why the lights blinked all evening before anything failed.
  • Starting the pump first works only once. Run alone, the pump's start asks the engine for about 17 kW, a little over its 16 kW rating, and it gets away with it. But the float calls the pump again whenever the tank runs low. At 1:40 in the morning the cold room and the wards are on too, the start needs about 24 kW, and the generator stops again.
  • The options. A set big enough to start the pump direct with a dip of about a fifth would be about 48 kVA. It would cost twice as much and run at a third of its rating or less, which leads to wet stacking. A soft starter at three times running current would still dip the voltage 23%. A 7.5 kW variable-speed drive draws about 7 kVA and dips it about 8%. It needs an output reactor to protect the motor at the end of 80 m of cable, and a ramp to 30 Hz within a second so the pump's thrust bearing gets its water film.

The parish priest refuses the bigger generator. The drive is paid for out of the fund for a new delivery bed, which now waits until June.

Why this one

The bible's proposal asked for an engineering fault that a careful, honest assistant could make. "Add up the running watts and leave a margin" is a sum anyone can check, and it is right as far as it goes. The number that matters is a different one, and it lasts a second. Like the shelf's other stories, it ends on a sound: the pump coming up slowly, the way a man gets up from a low chair.

The story is fiction and its closing note is not electrical advice. Sizing a generator or choosing a starter is work for a qualified electrician, using the motor's and the generator's data.

All writing · More in Stories · All tools and research