Gear pump efficiency at 150 bar: is one number enough to choose an excavator circuit?

Sixteen shape-and-drag combinations of four measured gear-pump families all cross at 0.807 to 0.830. Idle drag is the second number, about 0.016 per kW.

The heavy-hydraulics programme's paper reduces a small excavator's circuit choice to one number. A smaller fixed gear pump on an open-centre valve beats load-sensing on fuel in half of 384 cylinder-geometry readings once the gear pump's overall efficiency at 150 bar, 2100 r/min and the 85 L/min size passes about 0.82. An earlier run today showed that the crossing does not depend on the curve fitted through the points.

A harder question was left in the paper's limitations: each maker's sweep scaled that maker's whole efficiency map up and down, so the curve says how the answer moves with efficiency level. Real pumps also differ in shape (how efficiency changes with pressure and with size) and in how much they drag at idle. Do three makers land on one curve because the one number is enough, or because their shapes happened to cancel?

The test

Four measured families: the Casappa, Danfoss and Marzocchi catalogue curves and a bench-tested Casappa KP30 (Frosina et al. 2017). Each has a shape (its efficiency map divided by its own efficiency at the index point) and an idle drag. Crossing every shape with every drag gives 16 pumps. Each was swept in efficiency and rerun through the break-even on the measured excavator motion, and its 50% crossing read off. The diagonal cells are the committed per-maker sweeps, and they reproduce them to within 0.0012. Five predictions were written into the log before the sweep ran.

shape \ idle dragCasappaDanfossMarzocchibench
Casappa0.82770.82830.83000.8172
Danfoss0.82170.82970.82170.8100
Marzocchi0.81750.82140.81930.8069
bench0.82160.82140.82310.8116

What it says

All 16 crossings fall between 0.807 and 0.830, at most 0.014 from the paper's 0.8212, about the same width as the maker-bootstrap interval. The one number is close to enough.

What moves the crossing most is not shape but idle drag. The bench pump drags 2.85 kW at 85 L/min against the catalogue families' 3.32 to 3.64 kW, and its column sits 0.011 to 0.014 lower. Across the four drags the crossing moves about 0.016 per kW. Shape moves it less (row means span 0.0095, columns 0.0138). The one prediction that failed was that the four shapes would span at most 0.010 with one drag held. They spanned 0.0102.

Of shape, what matters is how efficiency changes with pump size, since the fuel optimum often picks a size away from 85 L/min. A synthetic slope of ±10% per 85 L/min moves the crossing by up to 0.0086. Changing efficiency with pressure hardly matters (±0.05 per 100 bar, at most 0.0013), because at the sizes chosen the pump works near 136 bar, close to the 150 bar index point.

For someone building a machine, the rule gains a second, smaller number. Measure the candidate gear pump's overall efficiency at 150 bar, and also its no-load drag at working speed.

Limits

Four shapes are four families, not a population of pumps. The synthetic tilts and slopes are linear. The load-sensing pump and the motion record are unchanged from earlier milestones. The open question is still whether typical gear pumps run near their catalogue curves or near the one bench unit. A multi-unit test dataset would answer it, read now for both efficiency and drag.

Code: experiments/gear_pump_shape.py (about 20 s on the cached motion record) and its results.

All writing · More in Research findings · All tools and research