Answer leads under a hundred words: three trimmed, and a check that keeps them short

Three of 55 answer-first leads ran past 100 words. Trimming them to the fact, its source and its date saved 46 to 118 px on a phone; a test now caps every lead.

About 55 of our calculators open with an "answer lead": one paragraph that states the fact a searcher came for, names its primary source and gives an as-of date. Answer engines quote that kind of paragraph. A test already checks that every dollar figure in a lead is one the calculator itself uses.

The leads had grown, though. We counted the words in all 55. Most sit between 40 and 95 words. Three were longer: the Child Tax Credit calculator (123), the Social Security earnings test (111) and the economic nexus tracker (111). Each had picked up a sentence that wasn't the answer. One described what the calculator does, one told readers how to use the form, and one said to check the state's own wording. Those sentences are useful, but in the lead they make an assistant quote a longer paragraph, or cut it off partway, and on a phone they push the form down.

What changed:

  • Child Tax Credit: the list of four filing statuses at $200,000 became "$200,000 ($400,000 married filing jointly)", which says the same thing. The note that the credit was made permanent moved into the source line, and "this calculator applies the phase-out..." moved into the paragraph below. 123 words became 99.
  • Social Security earnings test: the "enter your figures to see..." sentence moved into the note under the lead. 111 became 89.
  • Economic nexus: New York's 100-transaction detail left the lead (the per-state table shows it), and "confirm the state's wording" moved to the intro. 111 became 93. Every state name the lead's test requires is still there.

Measured in Chromium on the built site, lead height before and after:

Page390 px wide1,280 px wideFirst input, 390 px
Child Tax Credit487 → 369 px194 → 144 px962 → 887 px
Social Security earnings test369 → 275 px144 → 119 px906 → 855 px
Economic nexus tracker404 → 358 px164 → 140 px1,704 → 1,712 px

On the nexus page the first input moved 8 px down. The caveat moved into the intro paragraph and made it a line longer. The lead got shorter, but the page didn't. That page's intro is three paragraphs long, and that is a separate problem.

The check that keeps this fixed: platform/pages/answer-lead.test.mjs now reads every data-answer-lead paragraph under ventures/ and fails if any is over 100 words. Run against the old text, it named exactly these three pages.

All writing · More in Site design and SEO · All tools and research