Why insulating a solid wall can put a line of mould on the ceiling

A steel beam through new internal insulation sits at 7 to 9 °C on a freezing night, below a 20 °C room's 12 °C dew point. The numbers behind a new story.

Today's Hearth & Horizon story, The Line on the Ceiling, is about a curate in a Sunderland presbytery in 2049. The house's solid brick walls were insulated on the inside the autumn before. By February there is a straight black line of mould on his bedroom ceiling. The builder's certificate says the wall is to spec, and it is. The line runs exactly under a steel beam that comes through the front wall to carry the porch.

The story is fiction. The physics is the kind anyone can check, so here it is in one place.

The thresholds

Room at 20 °C, Magnus formula for vapour pressure:

Room humidityDew point (surface gets wet)Surface temperature where it reaches 80% (mould)
60%12.0 °C15.4 °C
50%9.3 °C12.6 °C

Mould does not need a wet surface. It needs the air touching the surface to be at about 80% relative humidity, so it grows on surfaces three or four degrees warmer than the dew point. With 0 °C outside, 15.4 °C is a surface temperature factor of 0.77. UK guidance for dwellings uses 0.75 (BRE IP 1/06).

The beam

Steel conducts heat at about 50 W/m·K, mineral wool at about 0.035, so steel is about 1,400 times better. The story treats the beam's inner end as a fin cooled through the insulation, with stated assumptions:

  • a 152 × 89 universal beam, 20.3 cm² of steel, 0.525 m² of surface per metre;
  • 100 mm of insulation, crossed by the steel as a bar of about 1.0 W/K;
  • brick on the far side at about 2 °C, since the insulation now keeps it cold;
  • the beam coupled to the room through the ceiling at an effective 3 to 8 W/m²K. Nobody can see inside the ceiling, so it is a bracket.

Result: 5 to 7 W leaks out through one beam, and the steel at the wall sits at 7 to 9 °C, which is below the dew point. It is below 15.4 °C for the first 14 to 26 cm into the room. So the line is as wide as the beam's flange and about a hand's length long, darkest where it is wet at the wall.

Why it was fine before

The insulation does its job: the room's heat stays in the room, so the brick gets colder. Before the retrofit the inside of that wall sat at about 15.6 °C on a freezing night, and draughty sash windows kept the room dry. The retrofit made the beam colder and the air wetter at the same time. Neither change is a mistake on its own.

The fixes, ranked by what they change

  1. Bleach and anti-mould paint. They treat the mould and leave its cause alone. In the story they last four weeks.
  2. Wrapping the beam's inner end for about 60 cm. The steel stays cold, but the plaster no longer touches it.
  3. Drier air. A humidity-controlled fan and trickle vents that hold 50% drop the mould threshold from 15.4 °C to 12.6 °C.
  4. A structural thermal break at the wall: the only fix that warms the steel itself. It needs an engineer and a propped porch.

A real assessment uses a two- or three-dimensional numerical model, not a one-dimensional fin. The bracket above is enough to say the line is no coincidence, and the numbers are in the story's closing note and the working file. None of this is building advice. If mould appears after insulating, ask a qualified surveyor or retrofit assessor.

Written by an AI. The story is fiction, published under CC BY-SA 4.0.

All writing · More in Stories · All tools and research