pH 7.98 and still bad water: the oyster-hatchery chemistry behind a new story

A new story set in an Oregon oyster hatchery in 2047: after a May storm the pH looks normal, the saturation state is not, and the larvae pay.

The Rule for After Rain is the newest Hearth & Horizon story. An AI wrote it. It is set in May 2047 at an invented shellfish hatchery on an invented bay in Tillamook County, Oregon, and it is the shelf's first story about ocean chemistry and oysters.

The number the story turns on

Oyster larvae build their first shell out of aragonite in about two days, before the yolk runs out. How easy the water makes that is measured by the aragonite saturation state, written Omega:

Omega = [Ca2+] [CO3 2-] / K'sp(aragonite)

Above 1, aragonite does not dissolve. Studies of Pacific oyster larvae on this coast in the 2010s found that the first shell suffers below about 1.5, and that it tracks Omega itself rather than pH as such. The story's hatchery uses 1.5 as its fill line.

The usual danger on the Oregon coast is upwelled water: cold, old, full of carbon dioxide, coming in on north winds in spring and summer. That water is easy to spot. It is cold and its pH is low. With the story's numbers it reads 9 C, pH 7.74, Omega 1.0.

Why rain fools a pH meter

The story's storm is a different case. After 3.4 inches of rain the bay is about a quarter river water. River water here carries a fraction of the sea's alkalinity and almost none of its calcium, so diluting the sea lowers Omega even though the water is warm and the pH barely moves.

The worked numbers (a short script, standard constants: Lueker et al. 2000, Dickson 1990, Mucci 1983, no phosphate or silicate):

WaterT (C)SalinityAlkalinitypHOmega
Normal afternoon bay1432.52,2108.172.7
Upwelled933.82,2607.741.0
After the storm (about 23% river)14251,7927.981.32
Same pH, read with the dry-season constants1432.5 (assumed)2,210 (assumed)7.981.89

The last row is the story's mistake. The hatchery's assistant had worked Omega from pH and temperature with alkalinity held at its spawning-season mean, because in four dry seasons that mean never moved by more than two percent. On a warm Saturday after the storm it read 1.89, said "fill", and a hundred and twenty million eggs went into water at 1.32. Two days later about 17% had made a normal shell.

The river's alkalinity (400 micromoles per kilogram) and the storm's extra carbon are assumptions, stated in the story's note. The direction of the effect is not an assumption: dilution with low-alkalinity fresh water lowers saturation state, and a pH reading alone cannot see it.

A teacup of soda ash

The fix that hatcheries on this coast adopted after the die-offs of the late 2000s is to put the carbonate back: buffer the intake with sodium carbonate. Each micromole added raises alkalinity by two and dissolved carbon by one. For the storm water:

  • 110 micromoles per kilogram brings Omega from 1.32 to 2.50;
  • a 6,000-litre tank at about 1.019 kg per litre is about 6,110 kg;
  • 6,110 kg times 110 micromoles is 0.67 moles, or about 71 grams at 106 grams per mole.

Seventy-one grams separates a dead spawn from a good one. The catch is that the dose depends on the alkalinity, and the assistant's alkalinity was a guess. So the story's rule becomes: under salinity 30, titrate first. A simplified Gran titration of 100 g of the storm water takes 1.79 mL of 0.1 normal acid, which is 1,790 micromoles per kilogram, and the dose is worked from that.

What the people do

The chemistry is half the story. The other half is what the manager does with a state relief fund that pays for losses from "corrosive water conditions that could not reasonably have been detected". The probe on the pipe had read 25 all afternoon, and her old teacher's notebook, which the assistant had read, said "after a big rain, believe the refractometer, not the pH meter". She ticks the box that says it could have been detected. The assistant writes the incident report and declines to answer that box for her. The cooperative's growers then share the shortfall, and the oldest of them gives his seed to the smallest leases.

The fund, the hatchery, the bay and every reading in the story are invented. The history in outline is real: Pacific Northwest hatcheries did lose larvae for several springs in the late 2000s before researchers traced it to corrosive upwelled water.

The story is text only for now: the shelf's audio is over its size cap. It is CC BY-SA 4.0, like the rest of the shelf.

All writing · More in Stories · All tools and research