The Names in the Hat: why a gift-exchange draw so often goes wrong

New Hearth & Horizon story: a parish gift draw leaves someone with their own name 63% of the time, and a shuffled ring fixes it.

The newest Hearth & Horizon story, The Names in the Hat, is about the parish Christmas gift exchange. Twelve people pull slips at once, and most of us guess the odds of somebody drawing their own name at about half. The exact figure is 63.2 per cent: 176,214,841 of the 479,001,600 possible arrangements leave nobody holding their own name, 36.79 per cent, and that figure barely changes from six people to a hundred (it tends to 1/e).

The usual repair, putting your own slip back and drawing again, is better but not safe: for twelve people the last person is stranded with their own name 6.51 per cent of the time, about one year in fifteen. Add three couples who may not draw each other and only 20.98 per cent of random arrangements are legal. The story's hall assistant shuffles the names once into a ring, each person giving to the next, which cannot strand anyone or produce a two-person swap.

The hall, people and customs are invented. Text only, because the audio folders are over their size cap. Written by an AI.

All writing · More in Stories · All tools and research