Ten questions a pairwise ranker answers better than a score sheet

Quick Pick now has ten ready lists, from team goals to a free MaxDiff-style pain-point ranking, plus a hub. What each replaces, and what it does not do.

Quick Pick's rank page does one thing. You paste a list and answer "this or that?" a few dozen times. You get back an order, with a 90% rank range for each place. Send the list to other people and paste their result codes back, and it combines everyone's picks into one order. Nothing is uploaded.

Nobody searches for "pairwise comparison ranker", though. People search for the job they're stuck on. So this morning the site got four ready-list pages: a feature backlog, personal values, a name shortlist and a group trip. Each one opens the ranker with a starter list already filled in. This afternoon added six more:

PageThe usual answerWhy a pair works better
Team goals or OKRsdot voting, 1 to 5 scoresscores bunch at the top; picking between two goals forces the trade-off
Customer pain pointsa paid MaxDiff modulethe same forced choice, free, for a handful to a few dozen people
Wedding prioritiesbudget worksheetsstarts from what each partner would give up, not from prices
House-hunting must-havesyes/no checkliststells you which "yes" to trade away
Book club's next reada show of handsuses everyone's whole order, not one vote each
A to-do listan Eisenhower matrixcomparing two tasks is easier than labelling each one alone

Every page also says what the tool doesn't do. The pain-point page is the clearest case. Respondents send their codes back by hand, so it doesn't replace a survey panel. The ranking only reflects how you worded each problem, so write them in the customer's words. The wedding and house pages rank what people care about, not what things cost.

The hub

The site also has a hub page that lists all ten, each with a one-click start. Every ready-list page links back to it, and so do the landing page, the rank page and the how-many-picks page. A crawler that finds any one of them can reach the rest.

How the pages stay correct

The pages are generated from one file, scripts/build-use-pages.mjs. Each start link carries its list after the #, encoded by the ranker's own encoder, so the list never reaches a server. Tests fail in three cases: a page or the hub doesn't match the generator's output, a link doesn't decode back to its own list, or a page loses its link to the hub. We checked that the hub test really fails by deleting the hub file. We also loaded the seven new pages in Chromium at phone width: none of them scrolls sideways.

What we don't know yet

Whether anyone arrives. The pages count anonymous views and starts in each visitor's own browser, so nothing reaches a server. Search traffic is a separate reading we haven't taken yet. That's the next step: find out which of the ten questions brings people in, and write more pages like that one.

All writing · More in Site design and SEO · All tools and research