The tools at the foot of each page were the next four in the alphabet

Each tool page links to four related tools. In big categories that meant alphabetical neighbours: 2,974 of 5,512 links shared no word with the page. Now 14 do.

Every one of the catalogue's 1,378 tools ends with a short list called "More free tools": four links to other tools a reader of this one might want next. It is the main path from one tool to another, for people and for search engines, which read those links as a statement of what is related to what.

The list was chosen by tier: tools in the same sub-group first, then the same category, then the rest of the site. Only the trade bids have sub-groups. The other categories hold 35 to 219 tools each, and inside a tier the pick was a rotation by the tool's own position in the catalogue. Since the catalogue is sorted by name, that rotation came out as "the next four tools in the alphabet".

Two examples from the live site:

  • Vendor Watch, which watches a vendor's terms page and shows a diff when it changes, offered Vendor Change Evidence, Vendor Change Watch, a VPAT generator and a Wise statement converter. The first two are related only because their names sort beside it.
  • The Mann-Kendall trend test offered a forecast calibration check, a ranked-choice ballot counter, robust PCA and SPC charts.

What changed

The ranking now scores each pair of tools by the words their names and descriptions share. Each shared word is weighted by how rare it is across the catalogue (a word in 1 of 300 tools counts for much more than one in 1 of 6), and a word in both names counts four times one in both descriptions. Words the whole catalogue repeats, such as "free", "calculator" and "browser", count for nothing. The category still matters: sharing a category adds a bonus worth about one rare shared word, so when nothing overlaps the old tier order holds, but a tool elsewhere that shares a lot can beat a same-category tool that shares nothing.

Ranking by overlap has a side effect: popular tools get linked more and some tools get linked by nobody. A second pass fixes that the way the blog's related posts already do. Each tool that no footer links to takes the weakest slot of its closest match, but only when that slot's current tool is linked from somewhere else too.

Before and after

Measured on the 1,378 tools in the built catalogue (the same names and short descriptions, the old rule against the new one):

beforeafter
links that share no distinctive word with their page2,974 of 5,51214 of 5,512
tools that no other tool's footer links to361
most footers linking to one tool1318

The "no shared word" count uses the same word list the ranking uses, so it measures whether there is any overlap at all, not whether a person would judge the link a good one. The examples are a better check. Vendor Watch now offers Vendor Change Watch, Vendor Change Evidence, Public-Record Watch and MCP Supply-Chain Watch. The trend test offers STL decomposition, a Kalman smoother, a changepoint detector and dynamic time warping. The eBay fee calculator, which used to offer two product-CSV checks for Wix and WooCommerce, offers Where to Sell, a print-on-demand profit calculator and two other eBay tools.

The table above compares the two rules on the catalogue's short descriptions. The site build uses each tool's full description, and the built pages come out slightly better: no tool is left without an inbound link, and the most any one tool is linked from is 16 footers. AI Bookkeeper, which the short descriptions paired with two CRM import checks, links to the PayPal, Square, YouTube AdSense and Payoneer statement-to-journal converters in the build.

The code is relatedTools and relatedToolsTable in platform/pages/build.mjs, with tests in platform/pages/related-tools.test.mjs.

All writing · More in Site design and SEO · All tools and research