Method and rubric: portfolio/quality/README.md. Evidence per subject: portfolio/quality/audits/. Scores are before any fix; this round shipped none.
The number
2 of 5 randomly sampled subjects meet the bar (Wilson 95% interval 12% to 77%; five subjects is a small sample). The flagship is chosen, not sampled, and is reported apart. Across all rounds the sampled share is 19 of 99 before this round's six audits.
Subjects
| subject | stratum | meets bar | worst defect |
|---|---|---|---|
research/watchdog-twin | research | yes | Novelty overstated: run-length maths, Gilbert-Elliott loss and (m,K) constraints are classical, and the i.i.d.-versus-bursty gap follows by construction. A seeded bug in m_twin_approx passed all 12 tests. |
research/selfrep-reconcile | research | yes | The comparison is not like-for-like: two chains start at n=1, the kit-stock chain starts empty and must wait for a kit. Truncation is untested. |
platform/agents | platform | no | toJson prints any object reached twice as "[circular]", although nothing is circular. The 401(k) tool's ranked[0], the winning option, comes out as that string. No test covers it. |
ventures/mobile-welding-job-price-calculator | venture | no | opts() silently replaces a blank field with the example default: clearing "Materials" prices the job at $951, entering 0 gives $766. A seeded bug (rig wear on weld hours instead of on-site hours) passed all 31 tests. |
ventures/cabinet-refinishing-bid-calculator | venture | no | The README says to open index.html directly, but over file:// the script does not run. Dark-to-light adds labour but no paint gallons. |
ventures/photo-editing (flagship, round 2) | flagship | no | site/index.html still says the renderers are dry-run and that it does not grade, which is false, and gives a command that is not installed. Two of three seeded mutations survived. |
What was checked
Test suites ran everywhere (watchdog-twin 12/12, agents 16/16, welding 31/31, cabinet 120/120, reconcile 4/4). Outputs were recomputed with independent code: eight watchdog-twin numbers against a numpy absorbing-chain solve, three welding jobs against a separately written gross-up model (the default job: 589.5/0.77 + 180/0.97 = $951.14, the calculator says $951.15), three cabinet bids by hand, the photo-editing tilt meter and four image metrics against numpy.
Not at the bar
Four of six. Common causes: tests that do not pin the numbers a user acts on (mutations survived in four subjects), READMEs that tell a user to open an HTML file that needs a server, and a public page contradicting the code. The welding calculator headline margin is 19%, not the 20% typed, which its audit also notes.
Since the last round
The photo-editing page defects are unchanged since round 1 (lines 34, 40, 47, 51 of site/index.html); the score did not move.