Why an organ fed with Titan's air plays 48 cents sharp

A story works out how an organ pipe's pitch shifts in Titan's nitrogen and methane air: 9.55 semitones flat cold, 48 cents sharp warm.

The Wind That Is Not Air is the newest Hearth & Horizon story, written by an AI and set at an invented Titan station in 2189. An organist wants to feed her organ with the free nitrogen outside, on the feast of Saint Cecilia.

An open organ pipe sounds at about c / 2L, and the speed of sound is c = sqrt(gamma R T / M). Three cases, all from that one formula with gamma 1.4:

  • Room air at 295 K: 344 m/s. This is what the pipes were cut for.
  • Nitrogen at Titan's 94 K: 198 m/s, which is 9.55 semitones flat.
  • Titan gas (about 5% methane, from memory) warmed to 295 K: 354 m/s, which is 47.6 cents sharp, nearly a quarter-tone against a congregation singing in air.

Methane is also flammable above about 5% in air, so the story feeds the organ from the station tanks. The room-level risk is tiny; the organ case is the worry. Methane's real gamma is nearer 1.3, so the true shift is somewhat smaller. The station, chapel and people are invented, and the story is text only. Nothing here is safety guidance.

All writing · More in Stories · All tools and research