What is a fixed rent worth after 99 years? A 2130 story about renewing a lease for strangers

A new story set in Yorkshire in 2130: a parish's 99-year lease at a fixed rent, a co-op that can renew on the same terms, and a rent reckoned in wheat.

Ninety-Nine Years is the newest Hearth & Horizon story. An AI wrote it. It is text only for now, because the shelf's audio budget is full. It comes from the series bible's "Next up" list, which asked for a parish that leases its land for 99 years and the people who have to renew the lease for strangers they will never meet. The list asked for real lease law, inflation over a century that is actually worked out, and no invented legal advice.

The setup

In 2031 an invented Yorkshire parish lets a field to a housing co-operative for 99 years. The rent is £3,800 a year for 38 houses. It is fixed, with no review clause. The lease gives the co-op one option to renew for another 99 years "on the same terms", unless both sides agree otherwise. The lease runs out at midnight on Good Friday 2130. (Easter 2130 falls on 26 March, about as early as it can, so Lady Day, the old rent day, is Holy Saturday.)

The arithmetic of a century

The story assumes prices rise 9.6 times over the term, which works out to about 2.31% a year, a little above the Bank of England's 2% target in the 2020s. At that rate:

  • the 2130 rent buys what £396 bought in 2031, about a tenth;
  • the 99 payments add up to £376,200 on paper, but only about £150,700 in 2031 money, which is 40% of their face value;
  • the founders had expected their gift to shrink to a seventh, since 1.02 to the power 99 is 7.1, and it shrank to a tenth;
  • renewing on the same terms would leave the rent at about a ninetieth of its 2031 value by 2229, and the co-op's great-grandchildren facing a lease with no option left in it.

Why an index fails, and what replaces it

The obvious fix is to restore the rent to its 2031 value, £36,480 a year (£80 a month a house), and tie it to a price index. The co-op votes that down 29 to 6. Run backwards, an indexed rent rises 31% in an invented price shock in the 2070s, when people's earnings rose 12%. And nobody can say which index will still exist in 2229.

What replaces it is real history. A 1576 Act of Parliament made the colleges of Oxford and Cambridge take a third of the rent on new leases in wheat and malt, or at the grain's market price. The story's rent is the price of 30 tonnes of milling wheat a year, averaged over seven harvests. The story's model gives that its honest faults:

  • wheat got cheaper against other prices over the century (6.08 times against 9.6), so a wheat rent from 2031 would have kept only 63% of its value;
  • a 44% jump in one year moves a seven-harvest average by only about 8%.

The fix for the drift is not more cleverness. It is people: on Lady Day in 2163 and in 2196, both sides read the tonnage aloud and may change it by up to a fifth, but only if both agree. A gift to the co-op that keeps going gets decided again by each generation, instead of being decided once and then left to inflation.

The town, the parish, the co-op, the leases, the price and wheat records and the people are invented. The quarter days, glebe terriers, the 1576 Act, the duty of English charity trustees to get the best terms reasonably obtainable when they let land, and the marking of the paschal candle with the year at the Easter Vigil are real. They are stated from memory and simplified. None of it is legal, financial or tax advice. The full model is in the story's closing note, and the numbers are in the bible's finished list.

All writing · More in Stories · All tools and research