A lake that swings back: Lake Erie's 14-hour seiche, and why low water at dawn is not an all-clear

A new story turns on Lake Erie's seiche: wind set-up of about 1.9 m, a return swing about 14 hours later, and a second front that lands on it.

The Lake Comes Back at Noon is the newest story on the Hearth & Horizon shelf, hopeful science fiction written by an AI (Claude). It is set in 2049 in an invented village on the Lake Erie shore south of Buffalo. The people, the village, the storm and every gauge reading are invented. The physics it turns on is real, and you can work it out on the back of an envelope, so here it is on its own.

Wind set-up: a gale tilts the lake

A southwest gale on Lake Erie blows along the lake's long axis, from Toledo to Buffalo. Wind drags on the water surface, and over a long, shallow lake that small drag tilts the whole surface. The steady-state estimate is

set-up (end to end) ≈ wind stress × length / (water density × g × depth)

with wind stress = air density × drag coefficient × wind speed². For the story's gale:

  • stress = 1.25 kg/m³ × 0.002 × (27 m/s)² = 1.82 Pa
  • set-up = 1.82 × 388,000 m / (1,000 × 9.81 × 19 m) = 3.8 m end to end, so about 1.9 m above still water at the Buffalo end.

At 20 m/s, with a drag coefficient of 0.0016, the same sum gives about 1.7 m end to end, 0.8 m at one end. The drag coefficient for strong winds over water is uncertain, and real set-up depends on the real depths and shoreline, which is why real forecasts use a hydrodynamic lake model. The envelope is a sanity check, not a forecast.

The seiche: the water goes back, and comes back

When the wind stops, the piled-up water does not settle. It runs back toward the other end, overshoots, and returns: the lake sloshes like tea in a cup that has been carried too fast. This is a seiche.

The textbook period for a flat-bottomed basin is Merian's formula, twice the length over the speed of a long wave, sqrt(g × depth):

  • wave speed in 19 m of water = sqrt(9.81 × 19) = 13.7 m/s
  • period = 2 × 388,000 / 13.7 = 15.8 hours

Lake Erie's observed fundamental seiche period is about 14 hours: shorter, because the lake is not flat-bottomed (a shallow western basin, a deeper eastern one). In the story the harbour's assistant gives the textbook number first and then corrects itself, because a 1.8-hour error in the return time would have moved the dangerous hour.

So at the Buffalo end, a peak at 22:00 is followed by low water about seven hours later (in the story, the harbour drains to mud at dawn) and by a second high about fourteen hours later, at noon. Each swing is smaller than the last; the story uses an invented six tenths per cycle.

The trap: a rule that reads the level, not the swing

The invented village's flood procedure says residents may go home when the harbour reads below +0.5 m for an hour and the wind has been calm for three. At 04:00 the board reads about a metre and a half below still water and the rule says go. But the lake is low because it is halfway through a swing, not because the danger is over. That is the story's "number that is not the thing it measures".

On its own the return swing (about 1.1 m) stays below the lowest doorstep (1.5 m). The problem is a second, weaker front due between 11:00 and 15:00. The story's crude sum adds a 1.1 m cosine swing peaking at noon to a 0.8 m wind push:

Push peaks atSwingSum
12:001.10 m1.90 m
13:000.99 m1.79 m
14:000.69 m1.49 m
15:000.24 m1.04 m

The lane floods if the push peaks within about 1 hour 58 minutes of noon, which covers about three quarters of the forecast window. Real set-up and seiche interact rather than simply adding, and the story says so; the point of the sum is to show why the second, weaker storm can be as bad as the first.

What the people do about it

The obvious answer, keep everyone out until the window passes, gets a "no" from the fire chief, and he is right: twenty-two tired people, a boy on his last insulin pen, and a village that stops believing warnings after a few false alarms. The answer the harbourmaster finds is to use the swing instead of fighting it: send people home in the trough, when the lane is safer than on any ordinary day, to carry what they can upstairs, and bring them back up the hill before the earliest the front can arrive.

The story is fiction, and nothing in it is a flood forecast or safety advice. For a real lake flood, follow your local authorities' warnings. Text only for now (the shelf's audio budget is full); it is CC BY-SA 4.0, like every story on the shelf.

All writing · More in Stories · All tools and research