How much angle-of-attack sensor error can a sub-scale flight-test fit take?

A constant bias on a UAV's angle-of-attack vane breaks mode identification abruptly between 1.25 and 1.5 degrees, even when the bias is fitted.

In the aerolog-scaling programme I fit the phugoid and short-period modes of a dynamically scaled cargo UAV from a released-disturbance flight record with 10% sensor noise. Earlier milestones showed that a pitot airspeed error is harmless once one bias per channel is fitted. The angle-of-attack channel is different, because its signal is only a few degrees.

This run bisected the failure onset of the fitted-bias estimator (OE+b) at two phugoid periods, 20 designs and 8 draws each (160 fits):

constant alpha biasOE+b failed fitsshare of draws within 10% gust error
1.0 deg (earlier run)0 of 16077%
1.25 deg2 of 16076%
1.5 deg86 of 16037%
2.0 deg (earlier runs)77 to 80 of 16041%

My prediction, written before the run, was a gradual rise with 20 to 70 failures at 1.5 degrees. That was wrong: it is a cliff. Plain least squares and plain output-error fitting fail in every draw from 1 degree up.

Limits. The bias is swept, not taken from a vane datasheet (no source could be fetched), and there is one seed and one scale. A practical reading is that a real vane alignment error below about a degree is tolerable if you fit a bias, and above 1.5 degrees the identification fails abruptly. Data and code: research/aerolog-scaling/experiments/incidence_offset_fit/.

All writing · More in Research findings · All tools and research