Our two cloth models agree on the hanger once the cloth is stiff enough, and the KES table says how stiff

With shear set from measured KES G, stretch still moves a hanger arm's best width 1 cm, but above 800 N/m all four fabrics pick the 2D model's answer.

Yesterday's step in the hanger-codesign programme found a confound. In our 3D cloth sheet, the shear springs were tied to the stretch stiffness EA, so every "EA" sweep also swept shear. On a simulated drape test, shear carried most of the effect. The day before that, an EA sweep had moved the best arm width of a shallow 3 cm hanger arm by 1.5 cm. Was that shear too?

This step set the shear spring to each fabric's measured KES shear rigidity (26 to 89 N/m) and swept EA on its own. It ran 126 converged cases across four fabrics, with predictions committed before the run.

  • Stretch is still most of it. EA 40 to 800 N/m moves the best width by 1.0 cm on both the cotton jersey and the suiting (+2.0 to +1.0 cm). Shear accounts for the remaining third of the old 1.5 cm.
  • Above about 800 N/m the choice settles. At EA 800, 3200 and the stiffness derived from the KES data, every fabric picks +1.0 cm, with one exception: the shirting at 800 N/m picks +1.5 cm. At those stiffnesses the margins are 0.02 to 0.08 cm, well clear of the solver's own wobble (at most 0.008 cm).
  • That is the 2D chain's answer. At the KES-derived stiffness, the 3D sheet and the 2D chain pick the same width on all four fabrics. The half centimetre of disagreement we chased for three steps is a soft-cloth effect.

Where did the KES-derived stiffness come from? The table that gave us bending rigidity, weight and shear rigidity also lists tensile linearity (LT) and tensile energy (WT). With the tester's standard 500 gf/cm maximum load, those two numbers give the strain at that load, and a secant stiffness of 2,400 to 15,500 N/m. The load is an assumption, because the paper does not state it.

But a garment hanging on a robot's hanger pulls on its shoulder with a few N/m, not 490. A power-law curve that matches both LT and WT puts the stiffness at that load near 1,300 to 1,900 N/m for the suiting and over 5,000 for the elastane jersey, so their choice is settled. The cotton jersey (about 250 to 370 N/m) and the shirting (700 to 1,050) land right in the band where the choice flips between +1.0 and +1.5 cm.

So the one fabric measurement still missing is not another KES summary number. It is the toe of the tensile curve: how much a strip of T-shirt jersey stretches under the weight of a T-shirt. A spring scale and a ruler can measure that.

Simulation only, produced with AI assistance; nothing here is a measurement of real cloth. Code, numbers and the full log are in research/hanger-codesign.

All writing · More in Research findings · All tools and research