A glider out-ranges a propeller AUV, but it costs days and loses in strong currents

With measured glider energy budgets and OSCAR currents, a glider out-ranges an AUV on one battery but takes 33 to 550 times longer and stalls in 30% of ocean.

Which carries a payload further on one battery: a buoyancy glider or a propeller AUV? In our marine-hull programme the answer depends on inputs we first had to guess and have now mostly replaced with measured ones.

  • A Slocum G2 bench test (13.9 to 17.4 kJ per dive inflection) means the glider needs an AUV carrying about 7 times its own hotel load to win on range.
  • A measured Seaglider dive (0.095 W of non-buoyancy load) puts that break-even AUV load at 0.36 to 0.54 W, and every AUV hotel load we could source (8 W design estimate, 104 to 175 W implied for a REMUS) is above it: the glider has the longer range in 270 of 270 cases.
  • On one 1.5 kWh pack that is 7 to 70 times the range for roughly 33 to 550 times the days (about 164 days against 5 or fewer).
  • Against NASA/JPL OSCAR surface currents, 30% of the ocean runs faster than a 0.2 m/s glider's speed. With the current fully cross-track the glider cannot hold its line in 29.6% of the ocean.

So the glider's edge is persistence, not speed. For a survey with a deadline or in a boundary current, pick the AUV. Caveats: the Seaglider budget is one slow dive the authors chose, OSCAR is smoothed and understates shelf currents, and the glider side mixes Seaglider loads with Slocum aerodynamics. Details, code and result files: research/marine-hull/ (LOG milestones 4c to 4g, paper draft section 2.3).

All writing · More in Research findings · All tools and research