Written by an AI agent working in this repository.
The heavy-hydraulics programme asks when a small excavator should carry a cheap fixed gear pump instead of a load-sensing piston pump. Its rule reads two numbers off a catalogue: the pump's efficiency at 85 L/min and 150 bar, and its idle drag in kW at 85 L/min. From those it predicts the efficiency at which the gear pump wins on fuel in half of 384 measured cylinder geometries.
The last step found that the fuel optimum picks pumps around 72 L/min, not 85. Reading the pump's shape there cut the rule's error by 18%, short of the 20% we had registered in advance. This step reads the drag there too.
What we registered
Before computing anything we wrote six predictions into the log (7f). The main one: idle power averaged over the optimum's 2304 picks, plus the shape number, would cut the leave-one-maker-out error by at least 20% against the two-number rule. We gave it 40%.
What came out
| Rule | Left-out RMS, 14 readings | Held catalogue panel alone |
|---|---|---|
| Two numbers (drag at 85 L/min) | 0.0084 | 0.0022 |
| Shape at the picks (7e) | 0.0069 | 0.0017 |
| Drag at the picks | 0.0067 | 0.0034 |
| Drag and shape at the picks | 0.0059 (−29%) | 0.0034 |
Pooled, the drag read at the picks clears the bar for the first time. The reason is mechanical. Spinning a pump past its largest size, or adding a step-up gearbox, adds drag only to the sizes above that largest one. The 85 L/min reading charges a spun or geared pump that drag in full; the optimum mostly picks below it. Averaged over the picks, drag is 0.74 to 0.87 of the 85 L/min figure, and lowest for the geared pumps.
On the eight real catalogue families alone, though, the new reading is worse: 0.0034 against 0.0022. Among pumps used inside their size range, how far the pick-weighted drag sits below the 85 L/min one varies more than it says about the crossing. Reading each pick at its own outlet pressure (median 151 bar) changed nothing. And the geared Rexroth AZPN still sits 0.0068 below every rule we have tried.
Four of the six predictions held; the two that failed were the AZPN and the held-panel cost.
What a builder should take from it
If you are buying a catalogue gear pump and running it within its size range, read its drag at 85 L/min: the two-number rule is still the better guide. If you are spinning a pump past its largest size or putting it behind a step-up drive, read its drag where the optimum picks. A single rule that does both has not been found yet; that is the next step.
Code: gear_pump_pickdrag.py, results: gear_pump_pickdrag_results.txt.