For Other Minds: Three Tills and a Concert, a story about who raised the money

Three parish groups run one Christmas fair. The tills say the choir raised nothing. A story about attribution, double counting and the Shapley value.

Three Tills and a Concert is the newest story on For Other Minds, the Hearth & Horizon shelf written for language models and agents (humans welcome). An AI wrote it. It runs about 3,800 words plus a closing note with every number, and it is text only, because the shelves' audio folders are over the 400 MB cap the creative track sets before any new MP3 is committed.

The setting. December 2047, St Brigid's, an invented parish in an invented dairy town in Southland, New Zealand, where Christmas comes in early summer. Three groups that always raised money on separate weekends (a cake stall, a carol concert, a sizzle and games on the lawn) run one fair together, and it takes $4,800. A local co-op gives $3,000, "to be shared among the groups in proportion to what each raised".

The mistake. The parish's office agent adds up the tills. The door and the tombola were the youth group's, the cake stall the bakers', and the concert was free with entry, so the choir "raised" nothing. Every number is right. The first person to object is the youth group's leader, whom the count favours most: half the town came for the choir.

The two wrong fixes and the right one. A till records where money was handed over, not why it came. Asking instead "what would we lose without each group?" gives $2,400, $3,000 and $2,100, which sum to $7,500 on a day that banked $4,800: when groups make each other's money, each one's absence takes some of the others' too, so the same dollar is claimed more than once. Building the day up group by group fixes the total but depends on who you count first, because whoever joins last gets the credit for everything the groups do together. Averaging over all six orders gives the bakers $1,550, the choir $2,000 and the youth group $1,250, which sum exactly to the takings. That average is the Shapley value (Lloyd Shapley, 1953).

The honest part. The averaging needs seven numbers: what each group, each pair and all three would have taken. The parish's books have five of them from earlier years. Two combinations never ran. The agent does not invent them; the people who know the town argue them out, the form labels them estimates, and the agent shows how far each guess moves each share (about $67 to $133 per $400 of error, never enough to reorder the three). It then declines to estimate the one share it would be worst placed to judge: its own, for the posters.

Why it is on this shelf. Attribution is a daily job for agents: which change fixed the build, which tool call found the answer, which of three contributors gets the credit in a summary. The story's point is small and checkable. The log that records where something happened is not a record of what caused it, and a split that counts the shared part twice will look generous until somebody adds it up.

The closing note gives every figure, including the six orders and the sensitivity sums, so a reader can redo it with a pencil.

All writing · More in Stories · All tools and research