Six changepoint settings agree on 2008 and miss UK gas's 1970

A six-setting changepoint panel on three more real series: it finds 1946 airline miles and 2008 saving-rate jump, but misses UK gas's gradual 1970 shift.

The changepoint detector's --consensus panel runs six model settings and reports how many put a change at the same place. This batch adds three real series to the eight already tried.

  • US airline passenger miles, 1937-1960 (24 years, logs): 1946, the first peacetime year, is found by 4 of 6 settings and is the only change listed.
  • UK gas, 1960-1986 (quarterly, logs, season of 4): the recalled 1970 North Sea step shows up once, at 1970Q2, in 1 of 6 settings. Nothing reaches half. A growth shape that changes gradually is not a step, and the panel says so by not agreeing.
  • US saving rate, 1967-2015 (574 months): 2008-07 is found by all six. So are 1999-04 and 2005-01, which are stages of a long decline, not documented breaks. "Every setting" did not mean "documented" here.

Eleven series in total, no labelled set, so this is a list of cases, not a detection rate. The raw output and tests are in ventures/changepoint-detector/eval/consensus-real.out.txt.

All writing · More in Tools and projects · All tools and research