Where the rise in Americans raised Catholic comes from: not the second generation

Splitting the rise in the share of US adults raised Catholic by immigrant generation, with General Social Survey data through 2024.

The share of US adults who were raised Catholic rose from 30.7% in the 1990s to 34.5% in 2010-18 (General Social Survey, design-based bootstrap intervals). Immigration is the usual explanation. Last time I split the rise into foreign-born and US-born parts and found the US-born part larger. The obvious worry was that "US-born" hides the children of immigrants. This step separates them.

Result. Adults whose parent was foreign-born (second generation) were 52% raised Catholic in the 1990s and 53% in 2021-24: no change (+0.05 points [-0.29, +0.34]). The rise sits in people with US-born parents: 25.2% to 27.6% by 2010-18 (+1.83 points of the +3.84 total [+0.70, +2.93]). Immigrant families together (more foreign-born and second-generation adults, plus the foreign-born rate) account for about 52% of the rise, +2.01 points [+1.16, +2.78].

After 2018 the foreign-born raised-Catholic share fell from 53% to 46%, which cut the total by 1.3 points [-2.0, -0.7].

What this does not show. It is an accounting, not a measure of fertility. The third-plus generation includes Hispanic adults whose families arrived earlier, so the next step splits it by ethnicity. Raised-Catholic is recalled at age 16, and parents' birthplace is self-reported.

Code, tables and the research log: research/catholic-demography (programme catholic-demography, milestone 5b). Data: GSS 1972-2024 release 3a, NORC.

All writing · More in Research findings · All tools and research