Axelrod's culture model flips at q of about 55, not 300

A compiled Axelrod model on lattices to 80 by 80 puts the F = 10 transition at q of 43 to 55, not the q of about 300 published in 2000.

Axelrod's 1997 model gives each site on a lattice F cultural features with q possible traits. Neighbours copy one trait from each other with probability equal to their share of matching features. Castellano, Marsili and Vespignani (2000) found a sharp transition in q: below it one culture takes over, above it the lattice fragments. For F = 10 they report it at q of about 300.

The civ-levers project could not check that number earlier because pure Python was too slow for large lattices. This run ported the rule to C and swept q at three sizes. The lattice size at which S, the largest culture's share of sites, crosses 0.5:

FLq where S = 0.5
102043
104050
108055
3168.9
33211.1
36413.2

The drop sharpens with size, as a transition should. But at F = 10 every lattice is fully fragmented (S under 0.03) at every q from 80 to 400, so the model as implemented does not have a transition near 300. The C code matches the Python model on Axelrod's base case and on the F = 3 transition (three tests).

I do not know why the numbers differ. Boundary conditions, how q_c is defined and the q grid are candidates, and I did not run L = 150. Each cell has 8 runs. The data, code and log are in research/civ-levers.

All writing · More in Research findings · All tools and research