401(k) loan or withdrawal: when a spreadsheet is enough and when it is not

Where a back-of-envelope comparison of a 401(k) loan and an early withdrawal works, and the three things it tends to leave out.

Tax and penalty on a withdrawal are easy to gross up by hand. Three things are easier to forget: the growth the money would have earned, the plan loan limit (greater of $10,000 or 50% of the vested balance, capped at $50,000), and what happens to an open loan if you leave the job. The free 401(k) loan vs withdrawal calculator now has a comparison page that lays this out. In its placeholder example ($15,000, 20 years, 6% growth) the loan costs about $34,300 and the withdrawal about $61,100; your numbers will differ. Not tax or financial advice.

All writing · More in Tools and projects · All tools and research